Key result
Noninvasive evaluation of retinal microvascular structure is of increasing interest for cardiovascular risk stratification, but the optimal approach remains to be established.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This editorial highlights the potential and limitations of noninvasive retinal microvasculature evaluation for cardiovascular risk stratification, emphasizing the need for further studies to establish the most reliable and prognostically valuable approach.
The evaluation of microvascular structural alterations might provide clinically relevant information, in terms of a better stratification of cardiovascular risk, before and also during treatment [1]. The measurement by wire or pressure micromyography of the media to lumen ratio of subcutaneous small vessels obtained by local biopsies is generally considered the gold standard approach [1–3]. However, also according to the 2013 European Society of Hypertension/European Society of Cardiology Guidelines for the management of arterial hypertension [4], ‘the invasiveness of the method makes this approach unsuitable for general use’. This has stimulated the search for noninvasive but clinically reliable methods for the assessment of small resistance artery structure. The retinal microcirculation represents perhaps the only microvascular district that may be directly and relatively easily observed; in addition, the vasculature of the eye and that of the heart [5] or of the brain [6] share several common characteristics. Therefore, the easily accessible vessels of the eye may be considered, to some extent, a ‘window’ to the heart [5] and to the brain [6,7]. In order to overcome relevant limitations related to the Keith–Wegener–Barker classification of hypertensive retinopathy based on funduscopic or slit-lamp examination [4,8], more recently several parameters measured in the retinal vasculature have been proposed as clinically relevant, including the fractal dimensions, the ratio between arteriolar and venular external diameters [arteriolar to venular ratio (AVR)], the number of terminal branching of retinal vessels, and so forth [9]. In this regard, one of the first attempts to precisely quantify structural alterations of retinal microcirculation was made by Wong et al.[10]. By means of an automated computerized method, and using appropriate funduscameras, the authors have calculated AVR in circular segments of the retina. AVR resulted lower in hypertensive patients compared with normotensive controls [10]. A meta-analysis has confirmed that retinal arteriolar narrowing and venular widening are independently associated with an increased risk of hypertension [11]. However, its prognostic meaning remains controversial, as a correlation between AVR and incidence of cardiovascular events was detected only in women [10]. Further studies have substantially challenged the ability of this parameter to correctly stratify hypertensive patients according to the extent of target organ damage [4,12]. No relationship between quartiles of AVR and left ventricular mass, carotid artery intima–media thickness or urinary albumin excretion was observed [12]. The relationship between indices of retinal vessel calibre, such as AVR, central retinal arteriolar equivalent (CRAE) and central retinal vein equivalent (CRVE) has been analysed in a systematic review and individual participant meta-analysis: wider retinal venular calibre predicted stroke, whereas the calibre of retinal arterioles was not associated with stroke [13]. Advantages and limitations of different indices of retinal microvascular morphology have been addressed by Cheung et al.[9]. Although for some of them, some prognostic relevance was demonstrated [14], according to the 2013 European Society of Hypertension/European Society of Cardiology Guidelines for the management of arterial hypertension at least ‘retinal arteriolar and venular narrowing, similarly to capillary rarefaction in other vascular beds may be an early structural abnormality of hypertension but its additive value to identify patients at risk for other types of organ damage needs to be better defined’ [4]. The 2018 European Society of Hypertension/European Society of Cardiology Guidelines for the management of arterial hypertension, however, did not specifically address the possible clinical relevance of AVR [15]. Therefore, the clinical usefulness of the calculation of the AVR and of similar parameters, such as CRAE and CRVE), mainly based on the evaluation of the external diameter of retinal arterioles and venules seems to be partly uncertain [4,16,17]. It is also widely accepted that structural and mechanical alterations may occur both at the level of the microcirculation and in large conductance vessels [18,19], with possible interrelations between them [18–20]. In fact, a complex interplay between alterations that occur at the level of the microvasculature and changes in mechanical properties of large arteries was postulated [18–20], and many mechanisms, including pressure wave reflection from distal sites and transmission of pulsatile energy to microvessels may be involved [18–22]. This cross-talk between macrocirculation and microcirculation may also have therapeutic implications [19,20,23,24]. Evidences supporting the presence of significant relationships between indices of large artery compliance (carotid–femoral pulse wave velocity – cfPWV index, augmentation index or augmentation pressure, central blood pressure values) and either indices of subcutaneous small resistance artery structure (media-to-lumen ratio) [25] or retinal arteriolar structure [wall-to-lumen ratio (WLR)] [26,27] were made available in recent years. Also carotid stiffness seems to be significantly correlated with WLR of retinal arterioles [28]. In this issue of the Journal of Hypertension, Meyer et al.[29] investigated possible association between an index of large artery stiffness (cfPWV) and indices of retinal vessel caliber (CRAE and CRVE) in a population sample (Atherosclerosis Risk in Communities Study, ARIC). The author observed that cfPWV was associated with wider retinal venular caliber, but only in individuals without hypertension. The study substantially confirms that the evaluation of CRAE (central retinal arteriolar equivalent) and CRVE (central retinal vein equivalent) provides information of limited clinical value. As mentioned, the presence of significant association between indices of large artery distensibility and morphology of retinal arterioles (WLR), evaluated by a noninvasive approach [Scanning Laser Doppler Flowmetry (SLDF)] was recently demonstrated [26,27]. Using this approach, it was also observed that the WLR of retinal arteries, but not the AVR, has a certain prognostic relevance [30,31], as it is particularly increased in hypertensive patients having cerebrovascular event [30], and parallels other indices of vascular damage, such as the intima–media thickness of the carotid artery [31]. Few years ago, a novel and extremely promising approach was made commercially available: the direct measurement of wall to lumen of retinal arterioles using an adaptive optics imaging system [32]. This is a considerably improved version of a traditional funduscamera based on an approach originally applied to correct for aberrations in optical systems used in astronomy [32,33]. The system, thus provides images of a quality and resolution never previously obtained [33]. Recently, a direct comparison of the assessment of the media-to-lumen ratio of subcutaneous small resistance arteries evaluated by wire micromyography and the WLR evaluated by either adaptive optics or SLDF was performed in the same individuals [34]. The evaluation of the WLR of retinal arterioles by adaptive optics has some advantage over SLDF, because of a better reproducibility and a closer correlation with the media-to-lumen ratio of subcutaneous small resistance arteries) [34]. The main problem related to the evaluation of WLR of retinal arterioles with SLDF seemed to be the relatively suboptimal variability of the estimation of the internal diameter in real-life situations, because of the indirect nature of the measurement (Doppler perfusion images) [17,34], whereas the estimation of the morphological parameters of retinal arterioles by adaptive optics seems to be quite stable throughout a length of the vascular segment of at least 500 μm [32]. In conclusion, the possibility to reliably evaluate alterations in the retinal microvasculature noninvasively in a clinical setting is an appealing goal, as it might provide a meaningful insight into similar vascular alteration in the heart and the brain [5,6,17]. Although it may be relatively easy to associate morphological changes in the retinal arterial district and events/diseases, it is more difficult to understand the clinical role of changes in the venular side. Therefore, the clinical relevance of the evaluation of CRVE, as done in this study by Meyer et al.[29] is, to some extent, uncertain. It can, however, be safely affirmed that not all the available methods of investigation of morphological characteristics of the retinal vasculature are equally informative and useful. In conclusion, undoubtedly the interest in a noninvasive evaluation of microvascular structure is progressively increasing, and it could potentially represent, in the future, an evaluation to be performed in almost all hypertensive patients, in order to obtain a better stratification of cardiovascular risk, before and during antihypertensive therapy [17]. However, we have still to clearly establish, which may be the best noninvasive approach for the estimation of retinal microvascular structure, in terms of reliability, reproducibility, ease of use and prognostic value. At present, we have indeed too little information in this regard and further studies in this field are needed. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Conflicts of interest There are no conflicts of interest.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Rizzoni et al. (2020) conducted an editorial in Hypertension. Noninvasive evaluation of retinal microvasculature was evaluated. Noninvasive evaluation of retinal microvascular structure is of increasing interest for cardiovascular risk stratification, but the optimal approach remains to be established.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: