Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Coronary heart disease mortality and event rates have generally declined, though the relative contributions of changing event rates versus case fatality improvements vary by region.
In this issue the MONICA (monitoring trends and determinants in cardiovascular disease) team from Toulouse reports on myocardial infarction trends in south west France between 1985 and 1993. 1 There were 3263 events in men and there appeared to be an annual decrease of around 2% in both event rate and mortality rates. Twenty eight day case fatality fell by about 3% per year for first events and by 6% for recurrent events. The confidence intervals, however, are very wide around these estimates. The authors have concluded that the decrease in myocardial infarction mortality was predominantly attributable to reduction in case fatality and, by inference, improvements in acute management. It should be noted that there were few events in women. Curiously, the attack rates and case fatality rates in the present report are quite diVerent from those in the earlier one. In the overall MONICA analysis, 10 year trends in 37 populations highlighted mortality declines in the majority and substantial declines in 12 populations. n men, the annual mean change in coronary event rates averaged 4.3% compared with only 2.1% reduction in case fatality, an overall pattern very diVerent from the Toulouse experience. Another curiosity, however, is that the main MONICA report seems to show the pattern of change in Toulouse in keeping with the overall findings and, therefore, not as in the present report. 1 3 Having noted the substantial contributions from changes in survival, the MONICA investigators emphasised that "the major determinants of decline in CHD [coronary heart disease] mortality is whatever drives changing coronary event rates". he Toulouse paper highlights five key issues: trends in event rates, trends in mortality, trends in case fatality, inferences about treatment eVects (secondary prevention), and inferences about cardiovascular risk factors (primary prevention). 1 Coronary heart disease mortality statistics are the epidemiological rock to which all other phenomena can be most safely tied 4 . One of the great achievements of the MONICA programme has been the general validation of routine mortality statistics across the majority of the 21 countries. It is perhaps not surprising that two of the lowest coronary heart disease mortality rates are reported in Japan and in France where substantial numbers of coronary deaths are coded as something else. 5 However, the general trends are clear. In the majority of industrialised countries coronary heart disease mortality has fallen by a third or a half in the last two decades. Falls have been steeper in younger age groups and more aZuent social classes. 3 6 Trends in myocardial infarction and coronary heart disease event rates have generally mirrored trends in mortality. Various reports of increases in non-fatal acute myocardial infarction rates have a complex explanation which includes a reduction in hospital admission thresholds, an increase in the sensitivity of enzyme diagnostic tests, and financial pressures to recode non-specific coronary disease as frank acute myocardial infarction. rends in case fatality are easier to describe than to explain. The majority of reports from the USA, UK,
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Simon Capewell (2000) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: