Key result
Chloral hydrate sedation during pediatric imaging was associated with excessive sedation in 19% of patients, compared to 0% in the propofol group.
Why the study?
Does propofol compared to chloral hydrate reduce adverse events in children sedated for imaging studies?
Observational (n=455)
No
Does propofol compared to chloral hydrate reduce adverse events in children sedated for imaging studies?
Propofol appears to be associated with fewer adverse events such as excessive sedation and agitation compared to chloral hydrate for pediatric sedation during imaging.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Propofol may reduce excessive sedation risk versus chloral hydrate in pediatric imaging; cohort data leaves open need for RCTs before practice change.
We examined records of sedations provided by the paediatric anaesthesiology staff for 455 children (ages 1 mo-17 yr) undergoing MRI or CT scans at our institution over a twelve-month period with regard to the monitoring of adverse events: excessive sedation, agitation, vomiting, hypoxaemia, and major airway compromise. One hundred-and-thirty-one patients (29%) received chloral hydrate; 324 patients (71%) received propofol. All patients were monitored with continuous noninvasive pulse oximetry and received supplemental oxygen via nasal cannulae. Of the patients who received chloral hydrate, 64 (49%) were over one year of age; of the patients who received propofol, 318 (98%) were one year of age or older. In the chloral hydrate group, 23 patients (19%) were deemed excessively sedated and four patients (3%) were agitated; no patients in the propofol group experienced any of the adverse outcomes reviewed. Furthermore, no patients in either group had significant airway compromise and none was admitted to the hospital as a result of the sedation.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Merola et al. (1995) conducted an observational in Children undergoing MRI or CT scans (n=455). Chloral hydrate vs. Propofol was evaluated on excessive sedation. Chloral hydrate sedation during pediatric imaging was associated with excessive sedation in 19% of patients, compared to 0% in the propofol group.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: