Key result
Anaesthetists estimate operative blood loss with ~130 ml less error than surgeons.
Why the study?
Does subjective estimation of operative blood loss by anaesthetists provide a more reliable assessment of actual colorimetric blood loss than estimation by surgeons in patients undergoing surgery?
Cross-Sectional (n=100)
Single-blind
No
Does subjective estimation of operative blood loss by anaesthetists provide a more reliable assessment of actual colorimetric blood loss than estimation by surgeons in patients undergoing surgery?
Anaesthetists are significantly less unreliable than surgeons at subjectively estimating operative blood loss, though joint estimation is recommended when objective colorimetric or gravimetric measurement is impractical.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Anaesthetist estimates were associated with lower error than surgeon estimates; leaves open whether objective measurement should supplant subjective assessment in practice.
Altogether 100 cases were studied to compare the subjective estimates of operative blood loss by anaesthetists (six in number) and by surgeons (22 in number). Their estimates were compared with the blood loss measured by a colorimetric method, which was assumed to be the operative blood loss. The results showed that surgeons are less reliable judges of operative blood loss then anaesthetists. When objective measurement of operative blood loss is impracticable the anaesthetist and the surgeon should jointly make a subjective estimation.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
A. E. Delilkan (1972) conducted a cross-sectional in Patients undergoing elective or emergency surgery lasting at least 30 minutes (n=100). Subjective estimation of operative blood loss by anaesthetists vs. Subjective estimation of operative blood loss by surgeons (both compared against objective colorimetric Perometer measurement) was evaluated on Mean difference between actual operative blood loss (measured by colorimetric Perometer) and subjective estimation (in ml) (MD 129.5 ml, p=<0.01). Anaesthetists estimated operative blood loss more reliably than surgeons, with a mean error of 137.8 ml versus 267.3 ml compared to colorimetric measurement.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: