Key result
Clinical estimates underestimate perioperative blood loss by ~29% versus laboratory calculations.
Why the study?
Intraoperative blood loss predictions by anesthesiologists and surgeons vary greatly due to different observation angles, and whether these predictions accurately reflect actual blood loss remains debated.
Does clinical estimation by anesthesiologists and surgeons accurately reflect actual perioperative blood loss in major orthopedic surgeries?
Observational (n=60)
No
Does clinical estimation by anesthesiologists and surgeons accurately reflect actual perioperative blood loss in major orthopedic surgeries?
Clinical estimation of blood loss during major orthopedic surgery significantly underestimates actual blood loss, particularly when volumes exceed 1000 mL.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Clinical estimates underestimate lab-measured blood loss in major orthopedic surgery, with anesthesiologists more accurate than surgeons; leaves open need for objective quantification in high-volume cases.
Objective: Since the anesthesiologist and surgeon have different observation angles in the intraoperative period, their predictions based on clinical observation vary greatly.Whether these predictions accurately reflect actual blood loss is still a matter of debate.The aim of this study was to compare the clinical observations of anesthesiologists and surgeons on perioperative blood loss and transfusion requirements with laboratory results.Methods: Sixty patients who were scheduled for major orthopedic surgery were included in the study.Same anesthesiologist and the same surgeon were asked to estimate the amount of blood loss , and whether blood transfusion was needed during the perioperative period.The amount of blood loss was calculated synchronously using the perioperative hemoglobin value and the total blood volume.The blood loss estimates of the anesthesiologist and the surgeon were compared, with blood loss calculated in the laboratory.Results: The anesthesiologist's and the surgeon's estimates of perioperative mean blood loss volume were found to be lower than the blood volume calculated in the laboratory (p=0.01).When the estimated blood loss was less than 600 mL, it was considered as overestimation, and when it was more than 600 mL then it was interpreted as 20% underestimation (p=0.01).According to our findings, the rate of error in the perioperative blood loss estimates was 28.72%.When the blood loss was more than 1000 mL, the error rate of predictions was 34.03%; when it was less than 1000 mL, the error rate of predictions was 25.18%.Conclusion: We believe that when blood loss is more than 1000 mL in major orthopedic surgeries, the error in the estimation is increased, the amount of blood loss is difficult to predict, and the anesthesiologist makes a better prediction than the surgeon.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Yüzkat et al. (2019) conducted an observational in Major lower extremity bone fractures (n=60). Clinical estimation of blood loss vs. Laboratory calculated blood loss was evaluated on Perioperative mean blood loss volume (p=0.01). Clinical estimates of perioperative blood loss by both the anesthesiologist and surgeon were lower than laboratory-calculated volumes, with an average error rate of 28.72%.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: