Key result
In young, healthy adolescents, profound intraoperative hemodilution did not demonstrate a level of oxygen delivery at which oxygen consumption became delivery dependent, even at 260.2 mL/min/m2.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The authors emphasize caution in generalizing the tolerance of profound normovolemic anemia, noting that global measurements may miss organ-specific ischemic thresholds.
In Response: While we appreciate the enthusiastic response to our work, we feel that there are several points which must be emphasized with respect to Dr. Stemp's comments. First, we agree that the results of our study indicate that more profound levels of normovolemic anemia than previously described may be well tolerated in healthy, young patients. We do not know, however, specifically where the threshold of anemic shock is or which factors may influence this. Different conditions of anesthesia, surgery, patient age, or comorbid diseases may greatly influence where these thresholds lie. Therefore, we must be very cautious about generalizing these results and extrapolating to situations different from those described in our study. Furthermore, we can find no quantitative data regarding organ-specific thresholds of anemic shock (which may vary considerably) and, as emphasized by Dr. Stemp, whole body indices may well be misleading. Also, with regard to the issue of whether blood oxygen content or blood flow is the more important component of oxygen delivery, we do not think that our evidence definitively resolves this issue. There is some controlled intraoperative data regarding regulation of oxygen delivery by means of controlling cardiac output with cardiopulmonary bypass which suggests that the limit at which oxygen consumption becomes linearly dependent upon delivery occurs near 300-330 mL centered dot min (-1) centered dot m-2[1,2]. This same threshold has been described during normovolemic anemia in man in a single case report [3]. In this case report, the limit at which oxygen consumption became linearly dependent upon delivery was 184 mL centered dot min-1 centered dot m-2, which corresponded, in their patient, to a hemoglobin level of 4 g/dL. In our study, we did not demonstrate a level of oxygen delivery at which oxygen consumption became delivery dependent. The reasons for this are myriad but include the following: 1) our lower level of oxygen delivery may not have been low enough to reach this threshold at 260.2 +/- 57.1 mL centered dot min-1 centered dot m-2; 2) anesthetic conditions may influence where this threshold lies or whether it even exists; and 3) our patients were young, healthy adolescents without any comorbid diseases. While we agree that these data suggest that the relative influences of cardiac index and blood oxygen content may be different, the interdependency of this relationship and the paucity of controlled quantitative data make it impossible to state at this time which is the "more important component." Our current understanding of the present state of knowledge regarding this issue is that 1) very little is known regarding the pathophysiology of profound normovolemic anemia, 2) quantitative organ-specific measurements to determine individual organ thresholds of shock under these conditions are not presently available, 3) global measurements may fail to detect organ-specific effects, and 4) quantitative animal studies need to be done to determine where these thresholds lie and which (if any) of our presently obtainable clinical measurements correspond to these thresholds. It is clear that quantitative study of these questions necessitates organ-specific measurements and going beyond the tolerable limits in order to define where injury occurs. This cannot be done safely in humans. We caution readers to consider the limitations of our present knowledge very carefully before extrapolating and applying it to their individual clinical situations. John L. Fontana, MD Rolf Bunger, PhD, MD Departments of Anesthesiology and Physiology, Uniformed Services University of the Health Sciences, Bethesda, MD 20814
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Fontana et al. (1995) conducted a letter in Normovolemic anemia. Profound intraoperative hemodilution was evaluated on Level of oxygen delivery at which oxygen consumption becomes delivery dependent. In young, healthy adolescents, profound intraoperative hemodilution did not demonstrate a level of oxygen delivery at which oxygen consumption became delivery dependent, even at 260.2 mL/min/m2.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: