Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Depression in old ageDepression in old age is associated with a poor prognosis.This is confirmed by the results ofa recent study of 124 patients (36 men and 88 women) aged between 65 and 89.'The study was based on the findings at interview of new cases at referral and again one year later.All patients met standard criteria (Feighner criteria) for the diagnosis of primary depression.2Social and clinical features of the group were studied in depth, and antidepressant drugs, electroconvulsive therapy, and support by day hospital and outpatient facilities were used.Despite treatment, by the end of the year only just over one third of the patients had made a good recovery.Poor outcome was associated with the severity of the initial illness,3 those with depressive delusions being particularly vulnerable.Physical ill health was associated with a poor outcome, as was low social class-and this may reflect class differences in the experience of severe life events.Overall, 44 of the 124 patients recovered, 36 stayed the same, and 44 deteriorated or died.These results are similar to those reported by Post,4 5 who suggested that the apparent failure to improve prognosis after the introduction of electroconvulsive therapy and tricyclic antidepressant drugs might be due to a change in the selection of patients for admission.In Murphy's study outpatients were included but the prognosis remained poor.Possibly in old age a new "rule of three" should be constructed for the hospital treatment of depression: no matter what is done, a third get better, a third stay the same, and a third get worse.The dilemma is, of course, that in group studies actual treatment of the individual is masked.There are no comparable studies of outcome between groups ofolder and younger depressed patients, but Lieberman6 suggested that the elderly do not adapt to stress in the same way as the young.Traditional views of psychological health cannot be applied to the management of crises in old age.Failure to recognise key differences in the nature of depressive disorders in old and young may result in inappropriate treatment.During the follow up period of one year seven men and 10 women died, twice the expected rate at this age.The cause of death was obtained from the death certificates and covered a broad range of diagnoses.Kohn7 reported that in a survey of necropsy findings in 200 aged patients the cause of death in one third was "the aging syndrome ... which satisfies all the criteria of a disease."Fries8 stated that "when even the smallest perturbation prevents homoeostasis from being restored . . . the inevitable result is natural death, even
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
P.H. Millard (1983) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: