Key result
Triphasic waveforms with anodal RV electrodes lower defibrillation thresholds vs biphasic waveforms.
Why the study?
Triphasic defibrillation waveforms had been reported to cause less myocardial injury than biphasic waveforms, motivating a direct comparison of their defibrillation thresholds.
Do triphasic defibrillation waveforms reduce defibrillation thresholds compared to biphasic waveforms in a pig model?
Do triphasic defibrillation waveforms reduce defibrillation thresholds compared to biphasic waveforms in a pig model?
Triphasic waveforms can defibrillate more efficiently than biphasic waveforms with a 300-microF capacitor, but efficacy depends heavily on phase durations and electrode polarity.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Does not justify clinical adoption of triphasic waveforms; leaves open translation to human ICDs with optimized parameters.
BACKGROUND: It has been reported that triphasic defibrillation waveforms cause less myocardial injury than biphasic waveforms. This study compared the defibrillation thresholds (DFTs) of triphasic and biphasic waveforms. METHODS AND RESULTS: ++DFTs were determined for a transvenous lead system and a 300-microF-capacitor defibrillator. In 8 pigs (group 1), DFTs were determined for 5 triphasic waveforms with tilts of 80%, 83%, and 86% and for 1 biphasic waveform. DFTs were determined in another 8 pigs (group 2) for 2 triphasic and 4 biphasic waveforms with tilts of 43%, 49%, and 56%. In both groups, a biphasic waveform from a 140-microF-capacitor defibrillator was also evaluated, and both shock polarities were tested for each waveform. In group 1, with the 300-microF-capacitor defibrillator, the leading-edge voltage and energy stored at DFT were significantly lower for triphasic waveforms with phase-duration ratios of 50/33/17 and an anode at the right ventricular electrode for phase 1 than for biphasic waveforms (P<0.001). In group 2, the stored energy of triphasic waveforms with 56% and 49% tilt was significantly lower than that of biphasic waveforms with the same tilts for anodal but not cathodal phase 1 at the right ventricular electrode. Electrode polarity significantly affected the DFT of triphasic waveforms for both studies. CONCLUSIONS: Some 80% tilt triphasic waveforms defibrillate more efficiently than biphasic waveforms with a 300-microF-capacitor defibrillator. The triphasic waveforms for both groups were not superior to 140-microF-capacitor biphasic waveforms. The efficacy of triphasic waveforms depends on phase durations and electrode polarity.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Huang et al. (2000) studied Ventricular defibrillation (n=16). Triphasic waveforms vs. Biphasic waveforms was evaluated on Defibrillation thresholds (leading-edge voltage and energy stored) (p=<0.001). Triphasic waveforms with specific phase-duration ratios and anodal right ventricular electrodes lowered defibrillation thresholds compared to biphasic waveforms.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: