Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In reflecting on the dilemmas of globalization, Nicholas Burbules and Carlos Torres ask, "is globalization merely deleterious, or are there positive features associated with its practices and dynamics?" 1 This is certainly a difficult question; globalization is very complex and complicated and there is little consensus on its contours, dimensions, and impact.Among educators, it is largely unexplored.Most of my students and colleagues have little idea about the meaning of globalization, and critical conversations about it are conspicuously absent in prevailing educational reform proposals.Similarly, while some educational philosophers have been writing about globalization, it has not significantly affected how we think about our larger purposes or our field of study.Yet globalization has many negative consequences that ought to trouble us, and even make us rethink our passions and priorities.For example, it is not hard to show that the unfettered expansion of freemarket capitalism, a defining feature of globalization, has made the suffering and social injustice in our world markedly worse.We see growing gaps between the wealthy and the poor, loss of job security, exploitation of workers, privatization of public goods and services, environmental destruction, diminishment of biodiversity, disruption of indigenous cultures, loss of community, increased global homogenization, and ultimately, the almost complete subordination of the developing world to the needs and desires of transnational corporations.While the devastating environmental and human costs of globalization disproportionately affect citizens of poorer countries, they are not limited to them; the poor in wealthy countries face similarly bleak and insecure futures, especially when their jobs have been exported overseas.We can also see an increased sense of alienation and meaninglessness, and a loss of compassion, as people become increasingly seduced by hyperconsumptive, materialistic, greedy, and self-centered ways of being.Describing the deleterious impact of globalization, former Haitian president Jean-Bertrand Aristide writes that behind the crisis of dollars there is a human crisis: among the poor, immeasurable human suffering; among the others, the powerful, the policymakers, a poverty of spirit which has made a religion of the market and its invisible hand.A crisis of imagination so profound that the only measure of value is profit, the only measure of human progress is economic growth.2 Yet there is also positive potential within globalization.For example, there is more talk around the world about the meaning and importance of democracy, as well as a more widespread "belief in 'human rights' and the growth of organizations attempting to monitor and protect them." 3 We have previously unimaginable technology that allows us to communicate easily and quickly with others, to document abuses and suffering, to share ideas and resources, and to develop social justice networks and coalitions.And surely for some people, the benefits of capitalist expansion have trickled down, resulting in a higher everyday standard of living.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Kathy Hytten (2008) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: