Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The New Freedom Commission on Mental Health (2003), the World Health Organization report (2001), and the surgeon general (U.S. Department, 1999), highlight the need for evidence-based practice (EBP) in mental health. Evidence-based practice models often indicate the use of empirically supported interventions (ESI). Concurrently, recovery orientations have received increased emphasis, guiding the policies and practices in many state mental health systems. Some researchers argue that existing EBP/ESI research is deficient within a recovery philosophy and mission, while others acknowledge EBP/ESI as supporting recovery. To address this argument, two empirically supported interventions; Family Psychoeducation (FPE) and Interpersonal Psychotherapy (IPT) are considered. Both ESI have been identified by the New Freedom Commission (2003) as effective, state-of-the-art treatments for serious mental illnesses (SMI). This study addresses two questions: Are FPE and IPT congruent with 1) service-user-identified recovery-facilitating factors, and 2) service-user-identified recovery-hindering factors?Through a national research project to develop performance indicators for recovery for SMI, both recovery-facilitating and recovery-hindering factors have been identified by consumers and grouped under an ecologically based paradigm for mental health recovery. Using this framework, this article presents the fundamental mechanisms of FPE and IPT and compares these to consumer-identified factors that hinder or facilitate recovery. For each factor the core mechanisms, goals, and techniques of FPE and IPT were assessed to determine whether they support the facilitating or hindering factor. Because some factors contained multiple components, mechanisms supporting at least one factor component were judged congruent. This process was applied independently to both facilitating and hindering factors.Results by factor groups, both recovery-facilitating and -hindering, are reported and compared for IPT and FPE. For user-identified recovery-facilitating factors, IPT is judged to be congruent with sixty-three of eighty-seven recovery-facilitating factors (72%), and three of eighty-six recovery-hindering factors (3%). FPE is judged to be congruent with sixty-nine of eighty-seven user-identified recovery-facilitating factors (79%), and no recovery-hindering factors (0%).Current mental health policy calls for EBP, ESI, and a recovery orientation. While using practices supported by research evidence may be the best choice for many consumers, these practices may not be sufficient to fully support a recovery orientation. The findings in this exploratory study strongly support the recovery-oriented features of both IPT and FPE. However, as many recovery-facilitating factors cannot be addressed by individual or group mental health intervention, case management, advocacy, and support of client self-advocacy may be important practice considerations. Future policy should support ESI and empirically supported programs that are both recovery-facilitating and incorporate recovery-supporting mental health systems. Our findings indicate that IPT and FPE alone may not fully support a recovery orientation because some facilitating factors call for changes at broader system levels.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Bledsoe et al. (2008) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: