Key result
The EuroSCORE II risk model improves upon previous versions but faces ongoing limitations due to inconsistent definitions and registration of operative mortality across different health systems.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The commentary highlights the need for a uniform, widely-accepted definition of early operative-related mortality before applying complex mathematical adjustments to risk models like EuroSCORE II.
We read with great interest the article by Poullis [1] proposing that a recursive and non-linear regression model utilizing the EuroSCORE II risk model improves both its ROC and Hosmer-Lemeshow statistics. The European System for Cardiac Operative Risk Evaluation II (EuroSCORE II) is an updated tool for the prediction of in-hospital mortality after cardiac surgery, recently launched to replace the older additive and logistic EuroSCOREs developed in the late 1990s [2]. These previous versions have been extensively used in the last decade and have performed well, showing acceptable applicability to different populations of cardiac surgical patients [3]. However, the improvements in surgical techniques, the impact of open reporting of clinical outcome on medical behaviours and quality of practices, as well as changes in case mix have led to the loss of their predictive power and calibration. The new version is a result of refinement and modification of some of the established risk factors and the way the model evaluates them [2]. Its internal validation has showed a better calibration associated with a constant optimal discrimination and the few currently existing external validation studies may attest to an accuracy similar to the previous EuroSCORE and a much improved calibration. On the other hand, these studies have also expressed concern regarding an underestimation in the prediction of mortality, especially in high risk patients, or in those undergoing combined procedures [4]. Poullis' suggestion [1] for mathematical adjustments to the model using new methodologies certainly contributes to its performance improvement, but on the other hand, this confirms the observation that the updated EuroSCORE version seems to improve but not solve the original limitations of EuroSCORE I. However, it should not be overlooked, that the main measured variable by the model, namely operative mortality, is defined and registered differently among researchers, countries and national health systems. Poullis defined, in accordance to the original EuroSCORE II study by Nashef et al. [3], operative mortality as death at the institution where the surgery was performed. This may be convenient in order to assess most of the available information, but it does not reflect the "real" early operative-related mortality as perceived by either the patients or many cardiac surgeons in their everyday practice. Although a realistic approach seems to be the registration of death events occurring either within 30 days of cardiac surgery, and/or in the hospital prior to discharge to home, regardless of length of the hospital stay, the most reasonable follow-up time period to quantify early mortality for coronary bypass patients after adult cardiac surgery extends up to 3 months or more for valve or combined procedures patients [5]. As long as there is a lack of uniformity in what the model measures and what the surgical community measures, it is rather wise to first go one step back in defining a widely-accepted early operative-related mortality and then two steps forward by using mathematical adjustments like those suggested by Poullis [1]. Conflict of interest: none declared
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Spiliopoulos et al. (2014) conducted an editorial in Cardiac surgery. EuroSCORE II was evaluated. The EuroSCORE II risk model improves upon previous versions but faces ongoing limitations due to inconsistent definitions and registration of operative mortality across different health systems.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: