Key result
Björk-Shiley valves reduce mortality ~24% versus Lillehei-Kaster valves in combined aortic and mitral replacement.
Why the study?
Does the Björk-Shiley disc valve improve clinical and hemodynamic outcomes compared to the Lillehei-Kaster disc valve in patients undergoing combined aortic and mitral valve replacement?
RCT (n=48)
Randomized at the beginning of the operation
Does the Björk-Shiley disc valve improve clinical and hemodynamic outcomes compared to the Lillehei-Kaster disc valve in patients undergoing combined aortic and mitral valve replacement?
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In patients undergoing combined aortic and mitral valve replacement, both Björk-Shiley and Lillehei-Kaster valves provided clinical improvement, but the Lillehei-Kaster valve was associated with a significant gradient in the aortic position.
The present series was comprised of 48 patients, 25 of whom received the Björk-Shiley (B-S) and 23 the Lillehei-Kaster (L-K) disc valves. The 2 groups were comparable with regard to age, and to preoperative clinical and hemodynamic status. The randomized selection was carried out at the beginning of the operation. The total mortality in the B-S and L-K groups was 16% and 21% respectively. All surviving patients were restudied 13-40 months (mean 27) after surgery. Late thromboembolic complications occurred in 2 patients with B-S and in 3 with L-K valves, all leaving minor neurological sequelae. There was a relatively large number of patients in the L-K group with unmeasurable values of haptoglobin, indicating more hemolysis in these patients. However, the difference was not statistically significant. The clinical and hemodynamic status was improved in both groups. In the aortic position a significant gradient was found across the L-K valve, while no significant obstruction in the flow was found in the B-S valve. The pulmonary arteriolar resistance was significantly higher in patients with B-S than in those with L-K valves. Otherwise, there was no significant differences between the 2 groups, neither with regard to clinical nor to hemodynamic status.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Rostad et al. (1979) conducted an RCT in Combined aortic and mitral valve disease (n=48). Björk-Shiley disc valve vs. Lillehei-Kaster disc valve was evaluated on Total mortality. Combined aortic and mitral valve replacement using the Björk-Shiley valve resulted in 16% total mortality compared to 21% with the Lillehei-Kaster valve over a mean follow-up of 27 months.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: