Key result
Automated oscillometric devices show no agreement with standard Doppler for measuring ABPI.
Why the study?
Does an automated oscillometric device accurately measure ankle-brachial pressure index compared to the standard Doppler ultrasound technique in healthy volunteers?
Observational (n=50)
Blinded investigators
Does an automated oscillometric device accurately measure ankle-brachial pressure index compared to the standard Doppler ultrasound technique in healthy volunteers?
Standard automated oscillometric devices are inaccurate and show substantial variation compared to standard Doppler for measuring ankle-brachial pressure index, and should not be used for this purpose in clinical settings.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Automated oscillometric ABPI lacks agreement with Doppler; should not yet change practice and leaves open validation in clinical populations.
BACKGROUND: The aim of the present study was to assess the accuracy of an automated oscillometric device (DINAMAP) in measuring ankle-brachial pressure index (ABPI) in the clinical setting. Results were then compared to those obtained using the standard Doppler technique. METHODS: A prospective comparative study of 50 healthy volunteers was carried out using a standard ward DINAMAP machine, hand-held Doppler and a 14 cm sphygmomanometer cuff. Three consecutive pressure readings were taken from all four limbs of the volunteers using both Doppler and DINAMAP techniques. The two techniques were carried out by different investigators who were blind to the findings of the other. The ABPI was calculated for each technique and the two techniques were compared. RESULTS: There was no significant agreement between the ABPI readings obtained by DINAMAP and those obtained by the standard Doppler technique. There was also a substantial variation in pressure readings produced by the DINAMAP for a given limb as measured by intraclass correlation of the three readings taken. CONCLUSIONS: There is no role for standard automated oscillometric devices in the calculation of ABPI in the vascular clinic.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Ramanathan et al. (2003) conducted an observational in Healthy (n=50). Automated oscillometric device (DINAMAP) vs. Standard Doppler ultrasound technique was evaluated on Agreement between ABPI readings obtained by DINAMAP and standard Doppler technique. An automated oscillometric device (DINAMAP) showed no significant agreement with the standard Doppler technique for measuring ankle-brachial pressure index.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: