Key result
Adrenaline-methacholine testing for autonomic function in psychiatric patients reveals highly variable techniques and contradictory results.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Critical review uncovers variable autonomic responses to methacholine in psychiatric cohorts, indicating widespread inconsistencies in diagnostic and prognostic test protocols.
In 1948, Funkenstein, Greenblatt and Solomon reported on a test of autonomic function which is clearly a combination of tests used by earlier workers (McWilliam, 1925; Sachs, 1936; Myerson et al., 1937; Gold, 1943; Altman, 1943). They reported a relationship between the changes in systolic blood pressure induced by injected adrenaline and methacholine and the clinical course, after electro-convulsive treatment in a group of psychiatric patients. This was followed by a considerable volume of work, published by Funkenstein and his colleagues, on the prognostic, diagnostic and other aspects of a test (the adrenaline-methacholine or Funkenstein test) which has aroused steadily increasing interest. The number of papers published has grown continually, and great variation exists in the techniques adopted and the scoring methods used. Some workers have confirmed the original findings whilst others have not. Thus the subsequent literature on the test has shown a pattern not unfamiliar in medicine; enthusiastic first publications followed by reports less satisfactory and more critical, and attempts to carry out a proper evaluation, producing many contradictory results.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
J. T. ROSE (1962) conducted a review in Depression / Psychiatric conditions. Adrenaline-methacholine (Funkenstein) test was evaluated. The literature on the adrenaline-methacholine (Funkenstein) test for autonomic function in psychiatric patients shows great variation in techniques and contradictory results.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: