Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This information should be given to patients in clear understandable language, adapted to the patients’ needs and intelligence [5] . The competence of patients to understand this information should be assessed by the endoscopist. A crucial unresolved issue is the amount of information that the endoscopist should provide the patient about the complication and mortality rates of diagnostic gastroscopy. A published survey concluded that most patients wish to be informed of a risk greater than 1: 1,000 [6] . On the contrary, another survey showed that 19% of gastroscopy patients wanted to know all possible complications [7] , and a third survey reported that 16% of clinical negligence specialists suggested that patients should be told of risks of 1: 1,000,000 [4] . Additional important issues in the process of informed consent include: (1) who should be the responsible per son to provide the information and obtain the consent form – endoscopist, referring physician, nurse assistant or another doctor of the staff [8, 9] , and (2) what is the best way to inform patients – verbally, leaflet, videotape, postal or e-mail letter [10] . Written information is undoubtedly useful and advisable, but cannot replace the need for doctor–patient verbal communication and discussion. Not least the timing of information is mandatory. Was information given at a counseling session with the patient a month before the examination or just before the patient was sedated for the procedure? Furthermore, nowadays several patients would wish to know the name of doctor who will be in charge or will perform the examination – consultant, trainee (supervised?) or a trained nurse. They would also like to know the years of experience and technical skills of the endoscopist [6, 11] , including personal success and complication rates [12] . In modern health care, paternalism has given place to shared information, shared decision making and shared responsibilities between doctors and patients [1] . To achieve these goals, doctors must give full and unbiased information to patients, provide adequate time for discussion, and encourage them to participate in the process of decision making. Informed consent is not a momentary action of getting patient’s signature on a form. It is a dynamic process of events which rests upon mutual respect and honors the doctor–patient relationship. Informed consent derives from the principle of respecting the patient’s autonomy, i.e., the patient has the right to decide about proposed treatment or procedure. The process of informed consent requires that the doctor explains to the patient the benefits and risks of any suggested test or treatment and obtains the patient’s deliberate agreement to proceed [2, 3] . Focusing this article on diagnostic endoscopy, informing a patient and obtaining written informed consent is not that simple because endoscopies are invasive procedures. What would a ‘reasonable patient’ wish to know so that he/she will be appropriately informed and make a deliberate decision [4] ? The elements of adequate disclosure should include: (1) the reason that gastroscopy is indicated; (2) the nature (description) of gastroscopy, i.e., what will happen before, during and after the procedure; (3) diagnostic benefits, including therapeutic options; (4) possible risks, complications and mortality rates; (5) alternative diagnostic tests and their advantages and disadvantages, as compared to gastroscopy, and (6) a clear explanation that the patient may withdraw consent at any time prior to endoscopy. Published online: July 11, 2006
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Spiros D. Ladas (2006) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: