Key result
FFTree approach linked to ~28% higher interobserver agreement vs FIGO for identifying fetuses unsuitable for STAN.
Why the study?
Traditional cardiotocography (CTG) classification table formats have poor interobserver agreement, risking false-negative STAN recordings if fetuses unsuitable for labor are not accurately identified.
Does FFTree CTG interpretation improve interobserver agreement compared to FIGO classification for assessing suitability for STAN monitoring?
Observational (n=36)
Yes
Does FFTree CTG interpretation improve interobserver agreement compared to FIGO classification for assessing suitability for STAN monitoring?
The FFTree physiological approach significantly improved interobserver agreement among expert obstetricians in identifying cases not suitable for STAN monitoring compared to the traditional FIGO classification.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
May enhance CTG interobserver agreement for STAN triage; leaves open prospective validation before clinical adoption.
INTRODUCTION: It is a shortcoming of traditional cardiotocography (CTG) classification table formats that CTG traces are frequently classified differently by different users, resulting in poor interobserver agreements. A fast-and-frugal tree (FFTree) flow chart may help provide better concordance because it is straightforward and has clearly structured binary questions with understandable "yes" or "no" responses. The initial triage to determine whether a fetus is suitable for labor when utilizing fetal ECG ST analysis (STAN) is very important, since a fetus with restricted capacity to respond to hypoxic stress may not generate STAN events and therefore may become falsely negative. This study aimed to compare physiology-focused FFTree CTG interpretation with FIGO classification for assessing the suitability for STAN monitoring. MATERIAL AND METHODS: A retrospective study of 36 CTG traces with a high proportion of adverse outcomes (17/36) selected from a European multicenter study database. Eight experienced European obstetricians evaluated the initial 40 minutes of the CTG recordings and judged whether STAN was a suitable fetal surveillance method and whether intervention was indicated. The experts rated the CTGs using the FFTree and FIGO classifications at least 6 weeks apart. Interobserver agreements were calculated using proportions of agreement and Fleiss' kappa (κ). RESULTS: The proportions of agreement for "not suitable for STAN" were for FIGO 47% (95% confidence interval [CI] 42%-52%) and for FFTree 60% (95% CI 56-64), ie a significant difference; the corresponding figures for "yes, suitable" were 74% (95% CI 71-77) and 70% (95% CI 67-74). For "intervention needed" the figures were 52% (95% CI 47-56) vs 58% (95% CI 54-62) and for "expectant management" 74% (95% CI 71-77) vs 72% (95% CI 69-75). Fleiss' κ agreement on "suitability for STAN" was 0.50 (95% CI 0.44-0.56) for the FIGO classification and 0.57 (95% CI 0.51-0.63) for the FFTree classification; the corresponding figures for "intervention or expectancy" were 0.53 (95% CI 0.47-0.59) and 0.57 (95% CI 0.51-0.63). CONCLUSIONS: The proportion of agreement among expert obstetricians using the FFTree physiological approach was significantly higher compared with the traditional FIGO classification system in rejecting cases not suitable for STAN monitoring. That might be of importance to avoid false negative STAN recordings. Other agreement figures were similar. It remains to be shown whether the FFTree simplicity will benefit less experienced users and how it will work in real-world clinical scenarios.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Pereira et al. (2023) conducted an observational in Fetal monitoring during labor (n=36). FFTree physiological approach vs. FIGO classification was evaluated on Proportion of agreement for 'not suitable for STAN'. The FFTree physiological approach improved interobserver agreement for identifying fetuses not suitable for STAN monitoring compared with traditional FIGO classification.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: