Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Methodological study derives minimum variance unbiased estimators of variance under normalizing transformations, improving statistical inference for skewed phenomena such as cloud seeding.
Neyman and Scott [12] considered the problem of estimating the mean of a distribution after some fixed Gaussian inducing transformation had been applied to the observations. More specifically, if a random variable x is observed then it is assumed that ξ = f⁻¹(x) has a Gaussian distribution with mean μ and variance σ². They find the minimum variance unbiased estimator (MVUE), θ, of θ̂ = E(x) in terms of the MVUE's of μ and σ². The heart of their solution is in taking a Taylor series expansion of f(ξ) around the origin and showing that the resulting infinite power series behaves like a finite one in the sense that the operations of taking expectations and summing can be reversed as required provided only that f(ξ) is an entire function of second order or less. This paper exploits the Taylor series expansion of f(ξ) around the mean to find the MVUE of φ² = E(x - θ)². It was motivated in part by the fact that recent research in cloud seeding has shown that the variance may be a more important parameter than the mean [8], [15], and also by a general concern with the class of recursive transformations defined on p. 651 of [12]. In addition the MVUE of Var (θ̂) for particular transformations is derived. The problems under consideration here have been considered by Finney [6], Sichel [14], and Meulenberg [11] for the logarithmic transformation i.e., f(ξ) = emξ. Their results provide a check on mine. Schmetterer [13] has interpreted the results of Neyman and Scott in terms of the solution h(μ̂, σ̂²) of the integral equation E h(μ̂, σ̂²) = E(x) where μ̂, σ̂² are the MVUE's for μ and σ². Kolmogorov [10] has also considered the problem of finding unbiased estimators in terms of the solutions of integral equations but he relies heavily upon the results of Blackwell [2] in using the sufficient statistics for (μ, σ²) to turn unbiased but inefficient estimators into the MVUE. The problem discussed here can be formulated as an integral equation: viz., find h(μ̂, σ̂²) such that E h⁽μ̂, σ̂²_ρ) = E x - E(x)² but the present author has not attempted to solve this problem in this way. Rather he has approached the problem by a straightforward application of the method of Neyman and Scott.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
M. H. Hoyle (1968) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: