Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Commentary Following the landmark observations of Letournel and Judet1, acetabular fracture surgeons recognized the formidable technical complexities associated with surgical reconstruction of acetabular fractures. The French pioneers evaluated their acetabular fixations with detailed radiographic and clinical assessments. Multiple postoperative radiographic features were recognized as predictors for late failure and total hip arthroplasty. Matta2 devised a more sophisticated postoperative radiographic technique to characterize a postoperative acetabular deformity and predilections for late failure. The current study evaluates the application of computed tomography (CT), which the authors employed in 227 postoperative evaluations. Their observations characterized deformities as a linear step and a gap. Overall, a step-off of ≥1 mm is poorly tolerated in all adult age groups, while a gap of ≥5 mm is an ominous predilection for symptomatic degenerative changes. Elderly patients are more vulnerable to impaction and comminution that predispose them to a late deformity and total hip arthroplasty3. The CT methodology used by the authors utilizes a specific region in the high weight-bearing dome as the zone of the optimal prognostic evaluation. Nevertheless, the authors recognized that this region did not necessarily represent the site of maximal deformity. Likewise, while this region might possess a step deformity, another region might display a gap deformity, or vice versa. A more exacting way to visualize the entire postoperative acetabular deformity is a 3-dimensional CT (3D-CT) with a disarticulation of the femoral head4,5. Most postreduction acetabular deformities are of a rotational nature, with the location of the smallest deformity dictated by the type of surgical approach. With a posterior approach, the smallest magnitude of residual, postreduction deformity is within the posterior wall or column, whereas with an extra-articular anterior approach, typically, the smallest postreduction deformity is in the anterior wall or column. Special bone-holding forceps are available to attempt to minimize the magnitude of the deformity on the opposite side of the fracture, most remotely situated with respect to the surgeon6. Nevertheless, the remote region remains difficult to anatomically reduce and to appreciate as a malreduction, despite the use of intraoperative fluoroscopy. The authors reported a 7.9% rate of anatomical reductions. As the time between the injury and the date of surgery increases, the issues with fracture reduction are exponentially magnified1. The major shortcoming of the postoperative disarticulated 3D-CT image is the difficulty in characterizing the complex deformity in a quantitative and prognostic fashion. Along the plane of the fracture, the deformity varies greatly in magnitude and degree of step and/or gap. Nevertheless, for an acetabular fracture expert, these images provide a sobering reminder of the difficulty with achieving reproducible anatomical reconstructions, and thereby optimizing late clinical results. In the current study, the authors acknowledge supplementary shortcomings of their method, including an accurate documentation and correction of acetabular impaction, especially in the posterior wall or the high anterosuperior dome. Likewise, abrasive damage or impaction of the femoral head was not documented in their study. The authors excluded patients who sustained a concomitant femoral head fracture. A question arises as to the indication for this methodology after a routine acetabular reconstruction. The CT study does not improve the clinical outcome for the patient, while it entails a financial expense and a radiation exposure. The current study encourages a consideration of related controversial aspects of clinical management. Foremost for the elderly and osteopenic patients is whether a preoperative evaluation is indicative of whether any type of surgical reconstruction would realistically culminate in an acetabulum with a viable, congruent articular surface. Historically, most experienced “experts” believed that they could achieve a congruent acetabulum in virtually all patients with acute, displaced acetabular fractures1. The recent literature has provided adequate confirmation that for select elderly osteopenic patients, this objective is unrealistic3,7. The principal therapeutic alternative is an acute total hip arthroplasty with a suitable reconstruction and stabilization of the fracture8. Multiple authors have confirmed the feasibility and durability of acute total hip arthroplasty9-11. A major focus becomes a meticulous preoperative evaluation of the fracture to fully characterize its extent, the presence of impaction and/or femoral head damage, and a consideration of a delay between the time of injury and time of surgery. While the radiographic assessment after the acetabular reconstruction is a valuable educational method for the surgeon, the preoperative imaging analysis to document the extent of the injury remains the principal focus.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Dana C. Mears (2018) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: