Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Trial effect: a sum of many effects A trial effect is considered a benefit that trial participants experience merely by the act of trial participation. The experimental treatment effect, protocol effect, care effect, Hawthorne effect and the placebo effect, are all potential components of an overall trial effect and the terms ‘participation benefit’ or ‘participation effect’ have been used to cover four out of the five effects (excludes treatment effect). Similarly, older studies referred to a trial effect as an ‘inclusion benefit’ [1,2]. The experimental treatment effect is thought to occur when treatment offered in a study is better than the current standard of care and would be expected to accrue only to subjects randomized to the experimental therapy. The protocol effect is a possible benefit arising from closely adhering to the treatment regimens and procedures that are clearly outlined in the clinical trial’s manual. The care effect arises from differences in care between trial and non-trial participants that may not be specifically codified in the protocol. The Hawthorne effect is due to changes in patient or clinician behavior as a result of being under close observation in a trial. The placebo effect arises from psychologically mediated benefits associated with the administration of a sham or simulated intervention. The components of a participation effect are hypothesized to accrue to trial participants regardless of study arm and result in improved outcomes when comparing trial with non-trial participants.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Prema Menezes (2012) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: