Key result
Left-sided breast radiotherapy links to a ~120% higher incidence of abnormal TnI and CK-MBRI vs right-sided.
Why the study?
Does radiotherapy for left-sided breast cancer increase radiation-induced cardiac damage compared to right-sided breast cancer?
Cohort (n=80)
Does radiotherapy for left-sided breast cancer increase radiation-induced cardiac damage compared to right-sided breast cancer?
Left-sided radiotherapy for breast cancer is associated with higher cardiac radiation doses and an increased risk of subclinical cardiac damage at 1 year, detectable by LVEF reduction and elevated TnI and CK-MBRI.
LVEF decline ≥20% and persistent TnI/CK-MBRI rises may flag early cardiotoxicity after left-sided breast RT; leaves open utility of routine biomarker surveillance.
ObjectivesThe study aimed to evaluate the dose delivered to the heart during radiotherapy of left-sided and right-sided breast cancer (BC) patients, correlate the dose and laterality of radiotherapy to the possible cardiac damage and evaluate whether Left-ventricular Ejection Fraction (LVEF), Troponin-I (TnI), Creatinine Kinase (CK), Creatine Kinase-MB Relative Index (CK-MBRI) or Lactic Dehydrogenase (LDH) could be used to detect the possible onset of radiotherapy-related cardiotoxicity.Subjects and methods80 females were assigned as; 30 left-sided BC patients, 30 right-sided BC patients and 20 healthy females. Patients were treated by radical mastectomy followed by FAC-based chemotherapy and radiotherapy. CT-based 3D-planning was used to generate cardiac dose-volume histograms to assess mean dose received by the heart.Echocardiography was done to all patients before and 1 year after completing radiotherapy. In serum, TnI and CK-MB concentration and CK and LDH activities were determined before and 1 year after radiotherapy.ResultsIn left-sided patients, mean dose delivered to the heart was significantly higher in left-sided patients with significant association with total radiotherapy dose in left- but not right-sided patients. LVEF before and after radiotherapy were statistically different only in left-sided patients. LVEF one year after radiotherapy dropped 20% or more (ΔLVEF) in 6 patients, all were left-sided.Using cut-off values 0.08 ng/mL for TnI and 1.4 for CK-MBRI; 11 left-sided patients had abnormal TnI and CK-MBRI vs 5 right-sided patients, the 6 patients identified with ΔLVEF ≥ 20 were all among them.Conclusionthe mean dose delivered to the heart is significantly higher in left-sided patients, and it was correlated to the total radiotherapy dose. One year after radiotherapy, ΔLVEF is possibly good marker of cardiotoxicity onset, however, the persistent elevation of both TnI and CK-MBRI could identify both patients with cardiotoxicity and patients that are thought to be in subclinical phase of cardiac damage.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Zaher et al. (2018) conducted a cohort in Breast cancer (n=80). Radiotherapy for left-sided breast cancer vs. Radiotherapy for right-sided breast cancer was evaluated on Abnormal TnI (≥0.08 ng/mL) and CK-MBRI (≥1.4). One year after radiotherapy, left-sided breast cancer patients had a higher incidence of abnormal TnI and CK-MBRI compared to right-sided patients (36.7% vs 16.7%).
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: