Why the study?
Comparative benefits and limitations of different minimally invasive aortic valve replacement techniques remain unclear to guide clinical decision-making.
Do mini-thoracotomy (MT) and totally thoracoscopic (TT) approaches reduce short-term mortality and postoperative complications compared to mini-sternotomy (MS) in patients undergoing elective and isolated minimally invasive aortic valve replacement?
Meta-Analysis (n=34,573)
Yes
Do mini-thoracotomy (MT) and totally thoracoscopic (TT) approaches reduce short-term mortality and postoperative complications compared to mini-sternotomy (MS) in patients undergoing elective and isolated minimally invasive aortic valve replacement?
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In this network meta-analysis of 25 observational studies, short-term mortality was comparable across minimally invasive aortic valve replacement techniques, though the totally thoracoscopic approach was associated with shorter ICU and hospital stays, fewer neurological complications, and reduced blood loss despite longer cardiopulmonary bypass and cross-clamp times compared to mini-sternotomy.
OBJECTIVES: This investigation aimed to compare different minimally invasive techniques, namely, mini-sternotomy (MS), mini-thoracotomy (MT), and totally thoracoscopic (TT) approaches for the surgical treatment of aortic valve disease, emphasizing their respective benefits and limitations to guide clinical decision-making. METHODS: A systematic search was conducted in Medline, Web of Science, Scopus, Wiley Online Library, Google Scholar, and ProQuest. Studies were appraised using the Newcastle-Ottawa Scale. A frequentist network meta-analysis (NMA) with a random-effects model was employed to give reflective ranks and compare outcomes across techniques. Treatment ranking was based on p-scores, with MS as the reference. Higher p-scores indicate greater certainty of superiority over competing interventions. The primary outcome was mortality. RESULTS: Twenty-five observational studies (n = 34 573 patients) were included. Mortality did not differ between techniques (p-score: MS [0.85] ∼ MT [0.34] ∼ TT [0.31]). TT had longer cardiopulmonary bypass (mean difference [MD]: 41.04 [95% CI, 10.98-71.10]) and cross-clamp times (MD: 30.31 [95% CI, 5.81-54.80]) but offered the shortest intensive care unit (ICU) length of stay (p-score: TT [0.98] > MT [0.51] > MS [0.01]; MD: -16.00 [95% CI, -26.62 to -5.38]), reduced hospital stay (MD: -2.07 [95% CI, -3.77 to -0.37]), and fewer complications, including neurological events (odds ratio: 1.79 [95% CI, 1.03-3.13]), blood loss (MD: 208.85 mL [95% CI, 102.29-315.40]) compared to MS. MT showed similar outcomes to MS, except for longer operative times (MD: 29.84 [95% CI, 8.35-51.32]) and shorter ICU stays (MD: -5.88 [95% CI, -11.10 to -0.67]). CONCLUSIONS: TT may offer advantages such as shorter hospital stays, reduced neurological complications, and less bleeding as compared to MS, although it is associated with longer operative times. However, as all included studies were observational, the findings should be interpreted with caution, and further NMA including only randomized trials is warranted.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Husen et al. (2025) conducted a meta-analysis in Aortic valve disease undergoing elective and isolated minimally invasive aortic valve replacement (n=34,573). Totally thoracoscopic (TT) and mini-thoracotomy (MT) aortic valve replacement vs. Mini-sternotomy (MS) aortic valve replacement (reference) was evaluated on Short-term mortality (in-hospital up to 30 days).
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: