Key result
Novel overexertion in athletes frequently causes rhabdomyolysis with elevated CK risking misdiagnosis as liver injury.
Why the study?
Exertional rhabdomyolysis is more common than generally realized and its clinical aspects need to be better understood by physicians and athletic trainers to keep athletes safe.
Physicians should recognize that elevated "liver chemistries" in athletes may actually indicate exertional rhabdomyolysis, which is typically caused by novel overexertion and requires monitoring of serum CK levels.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Supports CK testing in athletes with isolated transaminase rises; leaves open optimal prevention protocols.
INTRODUCTION The causes and consequences of exertional rhabdomyolysis are often discussed among sports medicine physicians. I believe that rhabdomyolysis - usually mild or moderate in severity - is more common than is generally realized. To help athletes thrive and to keep them safe, physicians and athletic trainers must know the clinical aspects of exertional rhabdomyolysis. The scope of rhabdomyolysis, however, is too broad for a brief column, so I will cover pearls, pitfalls, and lessons learned. PITFALL: WHEN ARE "LIVER CHEMISTRIES" NOT LIVER CHEMISTRIES? Over the past 10 years, I've seen dozens of athletes with rhabdomyolysis, including runners who overtrain, soccer, volleyball, and basketball players with "heavy legs," strength athletes lifting weights too heavy for them, gymnasts sore and stiff, athletes doing stationary cycling against too much resistance, and athletes with staleness, fatigue, and "elevated liver chemistries." These athletes, however, also have elevated serum creatine kinase (CK) levels. The "liver chemistries" (high transaminases and lactic dehydrogenase) come not from liver but from muscle, from exertional rhabdomyolysis (1). This is why a serum CK should be part of the complete metabolic panel in, for example, a college health center. Otherwise, "liver chemistries" can be red herrings. PEARL: TOO MUCH, TOO FAST The diverse predisposing factors for acute rhabdomyolysis include features of the exerciser (overweight or unfit), features of illness (fever, viremia, or diarrhea with low potassium), features of the environment (heat stress), inborn metabolic myopathies, or certain drugs (2). But the most common cause of acute exertional rhabdomyolysis in athletes is novel overexertion: doing too much, too fast of an exercise too new. Acute rhabdomyolysis is more pronounced if the exercise has a strong eccentric component (muscle-lengthening contractions), such as downhill running, plyometrics, or lowering weights (3). Many examples of novel overexertion exist in the medical literature on acute rhabdomyolysis. Examples include too many push-ups and other upper-body work, too many sit-ups, too many squat jumps, and too much weight training in a gym workout (4-7). Or, as discussed last fall in an online forum for sports medicine physicians, seven college swim-team members were hospitalized for acute rhabdomyolysis after doing timed push-ups and lifting tests early in training. PEARL: WHAT LEVEL OF CK IS "NORMAL FOR THE SPORT?" Frequently physicians see a CK level of 1000, 5000, or 10,000 U·L−1 in a given athlete training hard. Then comes the question, "What CK is normal for an athlete in this sport?" No clear answer exists: We need more research. But two studies in football offer some perspective. When 12 college players were studied during two-a-day practices, mean CK rose sharply, from a normal baseline of 204 U·L−1 to a mean of 5125 U·L−1 (with 1 player at 18,800 U·L−1) on day 4. Rise in CK correlated inversely with fitness. Mean CK was lower (1264 U·L−1) by day 10. Despite rises in CK in all 12 players, no player missed a practice or had medical issues (8). In another study, 23 National Football League players were assessed 2 d after a game. All players had elevated CK (mean 1028; peak 2475 U·L−1), but none complained of muscle soreness (9). So mild to moderate elevations in serum CK are common in football training and after football games. We need similar studies in other sports. LESSONS LEARNED: SOME CASES ARE EXPLOSIVE The clinical course of exertional rhabdomyolysis is usually mild to moderate, although some cases result in muscle compartment syndromes. Rhabdomyolysis associated with exertional heat illness can be serious or lethal, as in an Australian man who spent 5 months in intensive care after heatstroke - and rhabdomyolysis requiring amputation - in a footrace (10), or in the 3 college wrestlers who died in training in the fall of 1997 - trying to lose too much weight too fast and likely taking ephedra - of hyperthermia and rhabdomyolysis (11). The most explosive rhabdomyolysis, however, is that tied to exertional sickling in athletes with sickle-cell trait. This usually occurs when they are doing repeated sprints or timed laps. Because of logjamming of sickled red cells in vessels supplying the working muscles, explosive ischemic rhabdomyolysis ensues, with major lactic acidosis and a rapid rise in serum potassium, which can cause lethal arrhythmias or death from acute myoglobinuric renal failure (12). QUESTIONS ON MANAGEMENT What CK level merits hospital admission? No firm cutoff exists, since each case is unique. Serum CK levels up to 250,000 U·L−1 are not unusual in novel overexertion; in extreme cases, the CK can exceed 500,000 or even 1,000,000 U·L−1. Usually an athlete with a CK level of 20,000-50,000 U·L−1 who is stable in the emergency room and has normal serum creatinine and good urine output will recover smoothly with oral hydration and outpatient follow-up (13). If the athlete is admitted, without subsequent acute renal failure or compartment syndrome, how long is the hospital stay? The stay can be brief, a day or two, although at discharge the involved muscles may still be sore and swollen. When should the athlete return to play? It may take several days or several weeks for damaged muscles to return to full force (14). Some clinicians hold athletes out until CK levels drop to lower than 1000 U·L−1. In my experience, some athletes, when muscle soreness and stiffness are resolved, can begin gradual reconditioning when CK levels drop to lower than 5000 U·L−1. Athletes who are reconditioning after rhabdomyolysis should heed early fatigue and avoid prior triggering factors. These practical questions need more research for better answers.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
E. Randy Eichner (2008) conducted a review in Exertional rhabdomyolysis. Novel overexertion was evaluated. Novel overexertion in athletes frequently causes exertional rhabdomyolysis with elevated creatine kinase levels, which can be misdiagnosed as liver injury if not properly evaluated.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: