Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
How do citizens discuss solidarity during migration situations? And does securitization of migration go along with de-solidarization? This paper examines the individual level of citizens’ communication on solidarity (or not) with migrants along three main frames identified by the literature on solidarity and deservingness: economy, identity, and security. In contrast to existing studies, we offer a long-term perspective (2005–2019) which enables us to capture in a more precise way changes or continuities in solidarity discourses triggered by migration contexts. Compiling large corpora and relying on a corpus linguistic approach, we conduct a quantitative cross-time analysis, which combines content analysis, machine learning and dictionary-based methods. Germany serves as a representative case displaying both scenarios of ‘welcome` as well as ‘rejection culture’. The analysis reveals a primacy of the security frames in the public discourse in Germany, which was, albeit, not specifically induced but rather amplified by the 2015/16 migration crisis. Our findings counter, however, the assumption that the dominance of security frames during the migration crisis triggered a shift in discourse toward de-solidarization with migrants. Thus, our study makes an important contribution to the research on migration showing that solidarity and securitization are not necessarily opposite concepts in the public debate.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Kneuer et al. (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: