Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Philaenus spumarius L. has been identified as the main vector of Xylella fastidiosa, the bacterium causing a disease denoted as Olive Quick Decline Syndrome (OQDS) in Southern Italy. OQDS epidemics have been decimating olive orchards since 2013 and marks the first establishment and spread of this pathogen in the European territory. A major impediment to contain OQDS spread has been the lack of registered and approved pesticides for the control of P. spumarius on olive. From late 2017 to early 2018, only two commercial formulations of acetamiprid and delthametrin were officially registered in Italy. Hence, an urgent need exists to evaluate field efficacy of chemicals with different active ingredients, formulations, and modes of action to control the meadow spittlebug. From 2015 to 2017, six different field trials (A, B, C, D, E, and F) were conducted using a randomized block with six replicates per treatment including the untreated check and neonicotinoids as reference products with known efficacy against other Auchenorrhyncha. Each replicate consisted of a single olive branch confined in a net cage where a fixed number of adult spittlebugs (collected by sweeping net) were introduced before and after the insecticide applications. Applications were performed by spraying the entire canopy, using a water volume of 1,500 liter/ha, except for the treatments with Prev-AM in trial D (Table 4), for which this volume was also increased to 2,000 liter/ha. In addition, in trial F, the formulations containing dimethoate and imidacloprid were applied also by injections in the branches. Adult spittlebugs were collected by a sweeping net and a fixed number introduced in the cages before and after the insecticide applications. The efficacy and persistence of each application was determined by scoring spittlebug mortality at 3, 7, 10, and 15 DAT for the trials conducted in 2015, and up to 20 and 25 DAT in trials conducted in 2016 and 2017 (Tables 1–6). Statistical analyses were performed with the CoStat software program ver 6.204. Comparison among numeric data sets was conducted using the one-way ANOVA followed by Duncan’s Multiple Range test. Statistical significance was accepted for P-values ≤ 0.05 α-level (Tables 1–6). Mean values followed by the same letter, on the column, are not statistically different at the probability levels P < 0.05. Mean values followed by the same letter, on the column, are not statistically different at the probability levels P < 0.05. Under these experimental conditions, synthetic pyrethroids (Decis Jet [deltamethrin] and Karathe Zeon [lambda-cyhalothrin]) and neonicotinoids (Epik SL [acetamiprid], Confidor 200 O-Teq [imidacloprid], Actara 25 [thiamethoxan], and Luzindo WG [thiamethoxam mixed with clarantraniprole]) showed the highest mortality rates ranging from 76.7% to 100% at 3 DAT and persistence up to 15 DAT with mortality rates higher than 40% (Tables 2–6). Applications of organophosphorus insecticides (Perfektion or Rogor L40 [dimethoate], Reldan 22 [chlorpyrifos-methyl], and Dursban 75 WG [chlorpyrifos-ethyl]) had lower mortality rates than the neonicotinoids and pyrethroids, and in the case of Dursban 75 WG (chlorpyrifos-ethyl), results were inconsistent between the 2 yr of testing. Although initial mortality was recorded for Laser (spinosad) and Prev-AM (sweet orange essential oil) used at high volume of application, both showed poor or no persistence. No dead insects were recorded for the following treatments: Movento 48 SC (spirotetramat), Teppeki (flonicamid), Plenum (pymetrozine), Applaud Plus (buprofenzin), Pyganic (natural pyrethrin), and Neemazal (azadirachtin). Mean values followed by the same letter, on the column, are not statistically different at the probability levels P < 0.05. Mean values followed by the same letter, on the column, are not statistically different at the probability levels P < 0.05. Mean values followed by the same letter, on the column, are not statistically different at the probability levels P < 0.05. Mean values followed by the same letter, on the column, are not statistically different at the probability levels P < 0.05. Mean values followed by the same letter, on the column, are not statistically different at the probability levels P < 0.05. Mean values followed by the same letter, on the column, are not statistically different at the probability levels P < 0.05. Mean values followed by the same letter, on the column, are not statistically different at the probability levels P < 0.05. Mean values followed by the same letter, on the column, are not statistically different at the probability levels P < 0.05. Mean values followed by the same letter, on the column, are not statistically different at the probability levels P < 0.05. Mean values followed by the same letter, on the column, are not statistically different at the probability levels P < 0.05. Spray applications were more efficacious and rapid than injection. For example, at 3 DAT, mortality rates for imidachloprid were 98.3% vs 60%, respectively, and for dimethoate were 88.3% vs 55%, respectively. Conversely, formulations applied by injection showed slightly higher persistence at 20 DAT with Confidor 200 O-Teq (imidachloprid) mortality 75.8% vs 69.4%, for injection and spray; and for Perfektion (dimethoate) mortality at 20.7 vs 8.9, respectively (Table 6). These data on efficacy of different chemicals and formulations to control P. spumarius showed that neonicotinoids performed better than the other products. In general, however, for the majority of the products tested, low persistence was recorded. These results suggest that newer formulations and chemicals are needed along with trials to determine proper timing and number of applications for effective management of this vector. Moreover, an integrated pest management approach is needed to manage spittlebug populations along with a sustainable strategy to reduce progression of OQDS in olive groves. This research was supported in part by industry gifts of pesticides and by the research fundings from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 Research and innovation program under grant agreement no. 635646 “Pest Organisms Threatening Europe POnTE” and grant agreement no. 727987 “Xylella fastidiosa Active Containment Through a multidisciplinary-Oriented Research Strategy XF-ACTORS.”
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Dongiovanni et al. (2018) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: