Key result
Behavioral treatment offers no benefit over blood pressure monitoring alone for reducing systolic BP.
Why the study?
The comparative effects of behavioral treatment versus blood pressure monitoring on blood pressure change in unmedicated mild hypertensives were unclear.
Does behavioral treatment reduce blood pressure in unmedicated persons with mild hypertension compared to blood pressure monitoring alone?
RCT (n=158)
Stratified
Does behavioral treatment reduce blood pressure in unmedicated persons with mild hypertension compared to blood pressure monitoring alone?
Absolute Event Rate: 7.4% vs 9%
Behavioral treatment did not provide a significant advantage over blood pressure monitoring alone for reducing blood pressure in unmedicated mild hypertensives at the worksite.
Behavioral treatment adds no benefit over monitoring alone in mild hypertension; challenges expectations for behavioral interventions in unmedicated patients.
This industry-based randomized study compared the effects of behavioral treatment (BT) and blood pressure monitoring (BPM) on blood pressure (BP) change in 158 unmedicated persons with mild hypertension (diastolic blood pressure 90 to 104 mm Hg). Participants recruited by a three-stage screening were randomly assigned to BT or BPM groups and stratified by entry diastolic blood pressure (DBP), age, and sex. BT participants received relaxation training, with or without the addition of biofeedback, cognitive restructuring, and health behavior change components. During the study, all participants were followed by their usual care physicians and received medical advice. At 18 weeks into the study, after the BT groups completed training, both the BT and BPM groups showed significant reductions in systolic blood pressure (SBP) and DBP assessed in the company medical clinic (7.4 and 9.0 mm Hg SBP and 4.5 and 5.9 mm Hg DBP, respectively). These reductions were maintained throughout the 36-week follow-up period. Reductions in BP assessed at the participants' worksite were similar for BT and BPM participants throughout most of the trial, indicating little advantage to the inclusion of behavioral interventions over monitoring alone. Differences in BP changes observed among participants receiving various combinations of behavioral treatment components indicated that the cognitive restructuring component reduced SBP in the worksite by an additional 5.4 mm Hg (p less than 0.05). Possible explanations for the BP changes observed in the BPM group and implications of the results for the treatment of unmedicated mild hypertensives are discussed.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Chesney et al. (1987) conducted an RCT in Mild hypertension (n=158). Behavioral treatment (relaxation training) vs. Blood pressure monitoring was evaluated on Reduction in systolic blood pressure at 18 weeks (mm Hg). Behavioral treatment provided little advantage over blood pressure monitoring alone, with both groups showing similar reductions in systolic blood pressure (7.4 vs 9.0 mm Hg).
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: