Key result
Calibrating cTnI assays with native troponin complex reduces between-manufacturer bias to ~1.4-fold vs standard calibrators.
Why the study?
Assay-to-assay variation in measuring cardiac Troponin I concentrations in AMI serum samples is substantial and requires improved standardisation methods.
Does the use of native troponin complex as a calibrator reduce assay-to-assay variation in cTnI measurements compared to proprietary or free cTnI calibrators?
Does the use of native troponin complex as a calibrator reduce assay-to-assay variation in cTnI measurements compared to proprietary or free cTnI calibrators?
Using native troponin complex for calibration significantly reduces assay-to-assay variation in cTnI measurements, suggesting it as the preferred standard.
May harmonize cTnI assays across labs; hypothesis-generating and should not yet change calibration practice.
Six different cTnI assays (5 commercial and one assay under development) were run with either their own calibrators or with standard dilutions of different forms of cTnI (free or complexed). Twenty-one serum samples from 7 AMI patients were analysed using these combinations of calibrators and assay constructs. The range of cTnI concentrations as measured in AMI serum samples by different assays was more than 10-fold using each assays own standards or when using free native or recombinant cTnI. With recombinant or in vitro formed ternary cTnI-cTnT-TnC complexes the differences were smaller (3-fold). The lowest between-manufacturer bias (1.4-fold) was obtained when the heart tissue derived native troponin complex was used for the calibration of the assays. For all assays, calibrated against this troponin I complex, the recalculated cut-off values were within 0.1-0.25 microgram/L. We conclude that to reduce assay-to-assay variation, native troponin complex is presently the preferred alternative for the standardisation of cTnI assays.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Katrukha et al. (1999) studied Acute Myocardial Infarction (n=7). Heart tissue derived native troponin complex calibration vs. Assays' own calibrators or free cTnI was evaluated on Between-manufacturer bias. Calibration of cTnI assays using heart tissue derived native troponin complex reduced between-manufacturer bias to 1.4-fold, compared to >10-fold with assays' own standards.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: