Key result
Physicians express less confidence in non-extreme subjective mortality predictions compared to extreme estimates.
Why the study?
The relationship between a physician's subjective mortality prediction and the confidence level of that prediction in critically ill children was not well understood.
Does the level of confidence in a physician's subjective mortality prediction correlate with the predicted mortality risk in critically ill children?
Cohort (n=642)
No
Does the level of confidence in a physician's subjective mortality prediction correlate with the predicted mortality risk in critically ill children?
Physicians are less confident when making intermediate mortality predictions (5-95%) compared to extreme predictions (<5% or >95%) in critically ill children.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Physicians should approach intermediate mortality estimates cautiously in critically ill children; leaves open whether structured aids improve prognostic confidence.
OBJECTIVES: The objective of this study is to investigate the relationship between a physician's subjective mortality prediction and the level of confidence with which that mortality prediction is made. DESIGN AND PARTICIPANTS: The study is a prospective cohort of patients less than 18 years of age admitted to a tertiary Paediatric Intensive Care Unit (ICU) at a University Children's Hospital with a minimum length of ICU stay of 10 h. Paediatric ICU attending physicians and fellows provided mortality risk predictions and the level of confidence associated with these predictions on consecutive patients at the time of multidisciplinary rounds within 24 hours of admission to the paediatric ICU. Median confidence levels were compared across different ranges of mortality risk predictions. RESULTS: Data were collected on 642 of 713 eligible patients (36 deaths, 5.6%). Mortality predictions greater than 5% and less than 95% were made with significantly less confidence than those predictions <5% and >95%. Experience was associated with greater confidence in prognostication. CONCLUSIONS: We conclude that a physician's subjective mortality prediction may be dependent on the level of confidence in the prognosis; that is, a physician less confident in his or her prognosis is more likely to state an intermediate survival prediction. Measuring the level of confidence associated with mortality risk predictions (or any prognostic assessment) may therefore be important because different levels of confidence may translate into differences in a physician's therapeutic plans and their assessment of the patient's future.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Marcin et al. (2004) conducted a cohort in Critically ill children (n=642). Physician's subjective mortality prediction was evaluated on Relationship between mortality prediction and level of confidence. Physicians' subjective mortality predictions between 5% and 95% were made with significantly less confidence than predictions <5% and >95%.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: