Key result
Preventable HF readmission estimates vary wildly, highlighting a lack of consensus on definitions.
Why the study?
Definitions and measures of preventable readmissions for patients with heart failure are unclear and inconsistent, lacking integration and critique of current evidence.
This scoping review highlights the lack of consensus and substantial heterogeneity in defining and measuring preventable readmissions in heart failure, calling for standardized, disease-specific criteria.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Inconsistent preventable HF readmission definitions undermine quality metrics and benchmarking; challenges consensus and extends call for standardized criteria.
BACKGROUND: Heart failure (HF) remains a significant global health issue and poses challenges to patient families and healthcare systems through index hospitalizations and subsequent readmissions. The readmission rate has been utilized as a quality indicator, and a proportion of readmissions are perceived preventable. However, the definitions and measures of preventability remain unclear and inconsistent, lacking an explicit integration, analysis, and critique of current evidence. OBJECTIVES: This scoping review aims to improve the understanding of the definitions and measures of preventable readmissions for patients with HF, by identifying the judgements in published literature and examining the reasonings behind them. METHODS: Systematic literature searches with a search strategy combining three compartments describing preventability, readmission, and HF were conducted. The inclusion and exclusion were performed against prespecified eligibility criteria. RESULTS: A total of 15 papers were identified. Substantial heterogeneity was observed in study characteristics and judgement of preventability. The proportion of readmissions deemed preventable ranged vastly from 6.66 % to 86 % and required careful interpretation due to inconsistency of denominators. The reasonings behind preventability can be categorized into four groups based on nature, focus, and purpose. CONCLUSIONS: There is currently no consensus on definitions and measures of preventable readmissions for patients with HF. Scattered research efforts were observed with inconsistent and unstandardized methods, criteria, and data used for judgement of preventability. Adopting an identical readmission calculation framework is critical for fair comparison. The timeframe of readmission is worth further reconsideration and investigation. Comprehensive, explicit, and disease-specific judgement criteria for preventable readmissions are urgently needed.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Liu et al. (2025) conducted a review in Heart failure (n=15). Definitions and measures of preventable readmissions was evaluated on Proportion of readmissions deemed preventable. The proportion of heart failure readmissions deemed preventable ranged vastly from 6.66% to 86% across 15 studies, highlighting a lack of consensus on definitions and measures.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: