Key result
Three-point crutch ambulation is linked to ~32% higher oxygen uptake versus normal walking.
Why the study?
The energy consumption and physiological demands of unilateral nonweight-bearing three-point crutch ambulation in newly injured fracture patients were not well characterized.
Does three-point crutch ambulation increase energy consumption compared to normal walking in fracture patients?
Observational (n=25)
Does three-point crutch ambulation increase energy consumption compared to normal walking in fracture patients?
Three-point crutch ambulation is a severe exercise challenge requiring strenuous exertion under anaerobic conditions, explaining the severe restriction in ambulation for newly injured fracture patients.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
High metabolic cost of crutch ambulation may restrict early mobility in fracture patients; cross-sectional data leaves open need for prospective trials on adaptive strategies.
The energy consumption associated with unilateral nonweight-bearing (three-point) crutch ambulation was evaluated in a group of 25 newly injured fracture patients immobilized in a long or short leg cast. After 5 min of crutch ambulation, the rate of oxygen uptake was 32% greater than the value for normal walking (averaging 15.7 ml/kg-min); the heart rate was 53% greater than normal (averaging 153 beats/min); and the respiratory quotient was markedly elevated (averaging 1.03). In those subjects able to ambulate for 10 min, these values averaged 17.6 ml/kg-min and 173 beats/min, approaching the peak values for maximal upper extremity exercise. The prescription of three-point crutch ambulation is a severe exercise challenge requiring strenuous arm and shoulder exertion under anaerobic conditions. These findings account for the common clinical experience that the newly injured fracture patient, unable to weight bear on an injured limb and requiring crutches, is a severely restricted ambulator.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Waters et al. (1987) conducted an observational in fracture (n=25). unilateral nonweight-bearing (three-point) crutch ambulation vs. normal walking was evaluated on rate of oxygen uptake after 5 min of crutch ambulation (32% greater than normal walking). Three-point crutch ambulation in fracture patients increased oxygen uptake by 32% and heart rate by 53% (153 beats/min) compared to normal walking.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: