Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
As instances in which the capability approach to well-being and justice is applied to education continue to increase in both quantity and sophistication, it is imperative that we get clear on an essential difference that appears between two main versions of that approach: That version demonstrated in the work of Amartya Sen and that demonstrated in the work of Martha Nussbaum. Sen’s 1979 lecture “Equality of What?” laid some important groundwork for the capability approach and introduced some of its key terms and concepts; he has continued to develop that groundwork in the thirty-plus years since. 1 Nussbaum has done her own extraordinary work in more thoroughly extending the approach from its original grounding in economics to more generally political and philosophical contexts. Sen and Nussbaum, of course, have also worked collaboratively on the development of the capability approach, and in many important ways their thinking about the approach itself and its possibilities in various contexts overlaps. 2 But there remains a key component of the approach on which they explicitly disagree: The formation (or not) of a specific list of capabilities. Nussbaum has been one of the strongest proponents of such a list while Sen has remained decidedly cool to the idea of a prescribed and fixed list of capabilities. In this essay, I aim to flesh out this key difference between Sen and Nussbaum and to give particular attention to the implications that their different approaches to capabilities lists have for education. Drawing on the original work of both thinkers as well as the work of scholars influenced by them, I attempt to make some initial determinations regarding which thinker’s version of the capability approach is more appropriate to a specifically democratic education concerned with things like empowerment, agency, and the cultivation of skills required for participation in political deliberations and processes. To begin, however, a brief overview of the capability approach is necessary. THE CAPABILITY APPROACH One of the key characteristics of the capability approach is how it measures human well-being relative to other, more traditional measures. Sen’s own words are a useful starting point: The capability approach to a person’s advantage is concerned with evaluating it in terms of his or her actual ability to achieve various valuable functionings as a part of living. The corresponding approach to social advantage — for aggregative appraisal as well as for the choice of institutions and policy — takes the set of individual capabilities as constituting an indispensable and central part of the relevant informational base of such evaluation.3 From the perspective of the capability approach, traditional measures of well-being such as preference satisfaction, income, and even Rawlsian primary goods — the broadest and most promising of these three traditional measures — are insufficient
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Tony DeCesare (2011) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: