This is the authors' abstract. We don't add key points for this paper.
SU~I~IARYThe first-lactation milk and fat records of 24,995 artificially sired progeny and 32,831 naturally sired progeny were compared on a within herd-year-season contemporary comparison basis over a period of nearly 10 yr.The artificially sired progeny were superior in every year of calving from 1951 through 1959, for milk and fat production.The trend in superiority was generally upward, although the low point was in 1953, followed by an increase and then a slight decline until 1959, when the superiority was greatest.Evidently, more emphasis was placed on selection of sires according to fat production of progeny than milk production.Biases in estimation of superiority of artificially sired daughters would result if over-all season averages of artificially sired and naturally sired daughters were used.Artificial insemination of dairy cows has received wide acceptance in recent years.In New York, in 1960, more than half of the dairy cow population was bred artificially, Krumm (7).However, the question is often asked "What improvement in production has resulted from artificial insemination?"Robertson and Rendel (9) proposed a method for determining the difference between first-lactation daughters of sires used in artificial insemination (AI) and firstlactation natural-service daughters.These workers (9) reported a significant advantage for AI daughters of the British Friesian breed and slight but nonsignificant disadvantages for the Shorthorn and Guernsey breeds.The New Zealand Dairy Board (8) reported a superiority of 10 lb.fat for 2-yr.-oldartificially sired progeny over their naturally sired herd-mates.Several workers, using the contemporary comparison procedure of Robertson and Rendel (9), have estimated differences between AI and non-AI progeny for United States data Wadell and McGilliard (13) for Michigan herds; Tucker and Farthing (11) and Tucker, Legates and Farthing (12) for North Carolina data; Hahn, Carmon, and Miller (6) for Georgia herds; and Guderyon, Corley, and Duckwall (5) for Wisconsin records.Most of these studies, except for the last cited, have dealt with relatively few records.None has shown the trend of differences between AI and non-AI progeny over a period of years.The purpose of this study was to compare the first-lactation records of New York Holstein AI and non-AI progeny within the same herd-year-seasons over a period of nearly 10 yr., in an attempt to learn if artificial insemination has improved the dairy cattle population in New York. DATAThe 305-day, 2 ×, M.E.milk and fat records of 597,388 separate lactations of Holstein cows which calved between September 1, 1950, and November 30,
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Vleck et al. (1961) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: