Key result
Aerobic training reduces recovery HR by ~7 bpm and improves cardiometabolic profiles in obese sedentary women.
Why the study?
The effects of aerobic versus resistance training on cardiovascular and metabolic parameters in obese sedentary women were not well established.
Does aerobic or resistance training improve cardiovascular fitness, metabolic, and anthropometric parameters in obese sedentary females?
RCT (n=30)
Randomly grouped
No
Does aerobic or resistance training improve cardiovascular fitness, metabolic, and anthropometric parameters in obese sedentary females?
A 6-week aerobic training program significantly improves recovery heart rate, lipid profiles, and blood pressure in obese sedentary women, offering greater cardiovascular benefits than resistance training.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Exercise may improve cardiac and metabolic parameters in obese women; hypothesis-generating, requires larger trials before practice change.
PURPOSE: The present study was designed to evaluate the effects of aerobic and strength training on cardiac variables such as blood pressure, heart rate (HR), and metabolic parameters like cholesterol, high density lipoprotein (HDL), triglycerides and anthropometric parameters of obese women of Punjab. METHODS: This study was performed as an experimental study, in which subjects were randomly selected. There were thirty obese women, aged between 35-45yrs with body mass index (BMI) of above 30. Subjects were grouped into control (n=10), aerobic training (n=10) and resistance training (n=10). Aerobic training was given for three days a week at 60-70% of maximum HR for 6 weeks. Resistance training (Delorme and Watkins Technique) was given for alternate days for 6 weeks. HR and blood pressure were measured before and after the exercise. Recovery HR was also measured. RESULTS: The findings of the study indicate statistically significant differences in recovery heart rate [Pre-exercise: 97.40± 5.378 (mean±standard deviation (SD)), post-exercise: 90.70±4.599, t=8.066, P<0.001] and in post-diastolic blood pressure [Pre-exercise: 85±3.265, post-exercise: 86.20±2.820, P<0.001] in aerobic training and in systolic blood pressure [Pre- and post-exercise] in both training groups (P<0.001). Significant differences were observed in very low-density lipoprotein [pre-exercise: 28.10±1.415, post-exercise: 26.86±0.760, t=5.378] and HDL [pre-exercise: 45.40±3.533, post-exercise: 53.60±3.134, t=6.318] levels in aerobic training group with P<0.001. BMI and body fat percentage showed significant improvements in both training groups. CONCLUSION: Aerobic training is more beneficial and can be used as a preventive measure in patients who are at risk of developing cardiovascular diseases due to obesity.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Chaudhary et al. (2010) conducted an RCT in Obesity (n=30). Aerobic training vs. Resistance training and Control was evaluated on Recovery heart rate at 3 minutes post-exercise (pre-post difference) (MD 6.7, 95% CI 4.820-8.579, p=<0.001). Aerobic training reduced 3-minute recovery heart rate from 97.4 to 90.7 beats/min and improved blood pressure and lipid profiles in obese sedentary women.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: