Key result
Acute illness before appendectomy is linked to ~20% less wound hydroxyproline accumulation versus post-resolution cholecystectomy.
Why the study?
The influence of a brief preoperative illness on postoperative wound healing was not well understood, particularly its prolonged effects despite resolution of the illness.
Does immediate surgery during an acute preoperative illness reduce postoperative wound hydroxyproline accumulation compared to surgery performed after resolution of the acute illness?
Observational (n=64)
Does immediate surgery during an acute preoperative illness reduce postoperative wound hydroxyproline accumulation compared to surgery performed after resolution of the acute illness?
Effect estimate: 20% less
p-value: p=<0.02
A brief acute preoperative illness significantly depresses postoperative wound healing (collagen accumulation), demonstrating a more prolonged influence than usually anticipated.
In a study of wound healing at high altitude, subcutaneously implanted PTFE tubes were used to stimulate and measure accumulation of wound hydroxyproline (an index of collagen) in 26 patients who had appendectomy and in 38 patients who had cholecystectomy. Patient age, length of surgery, and postoperative recovery seemed to predict better healing in patients who had appendectomy, but there was a difference in the preoperative illness of the two groups: acute cholecystitis was treated medically and cholecystectomy performed after resolution of the acute phase of illness, whereas patients who had appendectomy were taken to surgery as soon as a diagnosis was made. It was observed that patients who had appendectomy accumulated 20% less hydroxyproline than patients who had cholecystectomy (p less than 0.02), and that the depression of hydroxyproline accumulation was significantly related to length of preoperative illness (p = 0.008). This decrease in wound hydroxyproline accumulation is attributed to the acute preoperative illness. Conceptually, this is a unique situation since the brief illness did not produce lasting debility, and the source of illness, the inflamed appendix, was not present during healing. This indicates that even a brief preoperative illness has a more prolonged influence on postoperative healing than usually anticipated.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Goodson et al. (1987) conducted an observational in Wound healing (n=64). Brief preoperative illness (immediate surgery for acute appendicitis) vs. Resolved preoperative illness (delayed surgery for acute cholecystitis) was evaluated on Accumulation of wound hydroxyproline (20% less, p=<0.02). A brief preoperative illness prior to appendectomy resulted in 20% less wound hydroxyproline accumulation compared to cholecystectomy performed after resolution of acute illness (p<0.02).
Synapse has enriched 3 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: