Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
VER SINCE Plato launched political science, justice and authority have been its two leading concepts. In his analysis, as in that of most writers, problem has been that of just authority, or of an authoritative justice. A very few writers have separated two concepts, or subordinated one to other. Machiavelli, for example, clearly did not have a very significant place for justice in his estimate of political process. In quite radical contrast, anarchists of nineteenth century despised authority but honored justice. They assumed that justice could subsist without authority, indeed, only without authority. Among those who held this position, Pierre-Joseph Proudhon (1809-1865) undoubtedly preeminent as theoretician, and in a day when authority more seriously challenged and condemned than ever before his thought deserves consideration. summary of my discourse, Proudhon declared in 1840,1 and no phrase could more accurately catch thrust and intent of all of his works, from strange, totally secular interpretation of meaning of Sabbath in 1839 to severe but sympathetic evaluation of political capacity of working classes in 1864. And although he meant at time primarily that he was asking for end of privilege, rather than providing a system of social reform, justice was never to Proudhon merely abolition of privileges. He had just insisted that his criticism of property as theft could serve as the preamble to our future constitution, and a few pages later announced that justice is guiding star of societies, axis on which political world turns, and standard of all transactions.2 As his thought developed, he came to see it even as the fundamental law of universe.3 Simultaneously force and idea, principle of all order and measure of all good, justice at center of all of Proudhon's thought his criticisms of contemporary social life, his theories of knowledge, history, and society, and his proposals for reform. Proudhon was convinced that mankind had always sought justice, and to some degree known it. What Justice if not sovereign essence that humanity has in all times adored under name of God, and that philosophy has sought under diverse names, from Idea of Plato to Rights of Man and Citizen of Revolution?4 Furthermore, as one would expect given Proudhon's pragmatic and experiential perspective, these products of human reflection are not unrelated to facts of social life. In his First Memoire, taking note that man an animal living in society, he asked, What are conditions, laws, of human society?
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
William H. Harbold (1969) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: