Key result
Visual heart rate feedback aligns self-reported stress with heart rate, varying by neuroticism and anxiety sensitivity.
Why the study?
The effects of physiology feedback on self-reported stress and its correspondence to physiological stress were not well understood.
Does visual feedback about heart rate improve the match between physiological and self-reported stress in participants executing short tasks?
Does visual feedback about heart rate improve the match between physiological and self-reported stress in participants executing short tasks?
Self-tracking of physiology with visual heart rate feedback improves body awareness and the match between physiological and self-reported stress, particularly for individuals high in neuroticism.
Physiology feedback aligns self-reported stress with heart rate in select individuals; leaves open whether wearables aid or impair stress perception by personality.
Over the past years self-tracking of physiological parameters has become increasingly common: more and more people are keeping track of aspects of their physiological state (e.g., heart rate, blood sugar, and blood pressure). To shed light on the possible effects of self-tracking of physiology, a study was conducted to test whether physiology feedback has acute effects on self-reported stress and the extent to which self-reported stress corresponds to physiological stress. In this study, participants executed several short tasks, while they were either shown visual feedback about their heart rate or not. Results show that self-reported stress is more in sync with heart rate for participants who received physiology feedback. Interactions between two personality factors (neuroticism and anxiety sensitivity) and feedback on the level of self-reported stress were found, indicating that while physiology feedback may be beneficial for individuals high in neuroticism, it may be detrimental for those high in anxiety sensitivity. Additional work is needed to establish how the results of this study may extend beyond immediate effects in a controlled lab setting, but our results do provide a first indication of how self-tracking of physiology may lead to better body awareness and how personality characteristics can help us predict which individuals are most likely to benefit from self-tracking of physiology.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Dijk et al. (2015) studied this question. Visual feedback about heart rate vs. No visual feedback was evaluated on Match between heart rate and self-reported stress. Visual feedback about heart rate resulted in self-reported stress being more in sync with heart rate, with effects varying by neuroticism and anxiety sensitivity.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: