Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
As the authors of the meta-analysis referred to in the correspondence by Armstrong et al, 2018Armstrong S. Bhide P. Jordan V. Pacey A. Farquhar C. Time-lapse systems for ART.Reprod. Biomed. Online. 2018; 36: 288-289Abstract Full Text Full Text PDF PubMed Scopus (7) Google Scholar, we would like to address the questions and comments posed. We agree with the statement by Armstrong et al, 2015Armstrong S. Arroll N. Cree L.M. Jordan V. Farquhar C. Time-lapse systems for embryo incubation and assessment in assisted reproduction.Cochrane Database Syst. Rev. 2015; (CD011320)https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD011320.pub2Crossref Scopus (95) Google Scholar, Armstrong et al, 2018Armstrong S. Bhide P. Jordan V. Pacey A. Farquhar C. Time-lapse systems for ART.Reprod. Biomed. Online. 2018; 36: 288-289Abstract Full Text Full Text PDF PubMed Scopus (7) Google Scholar, that one of the potential benefits of the time-lapse (TL) technique in human ART comes from undisturbed culture, allowing embryo morphology to be assessed without removal of embryos from the incubator. TL imaging also allows for more dynamic embryo assessment throughout embryo development, which is equally important. Thus, in clinical practice the TL technique is a combination of both of these features and although we understand that theoretically it makes sense to divide TL studies into the three categories identified by Armstrong et al, 2015Armstrong S. Arroll N. Cree L.M. Jordan V. Farquhar C. Time-lapse systems for embryo incubation and assessment in assisted reproduction.Cochrane Database Syst. Rev. 2015; (CD011320)https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD011320.pub2Crossref Scopus (95) Google Scholar, Armstrong et al, 2018Armstrong S. Bhide P. Jordan V. Pacey A. Farquhar C. Time-lapse systems for ART.Reprod. Biomed. Online. 2018; 36: 288-289Abstract Full Text Full Text PDF PubMed Scopus (7) Google Scholar, we have chosen to look at the method as a whole and to select a practical way to determine whether or not there is any positive effect of using TL in clinical practice. We believe that the two essential features of TL as described above should not be separated. Visual information includes both the scrolling of TL images back and forth and the use of multiple focal planes at different time-points to optimally assess multi-nucleation, cell number, fragmentation or blastocyst quality. These are dynamic processes, so a full evaluation on a single still image is impossible (Desai et al, 2014Desai N. Ploskonka S. Goodman L.R. Austin C. Goldberg J. Falcone T. Analysis of embryo morphokinetics, multinucleation and cleavage anomalies using continuous time-lapse monitoring in blastocyst transfer cycles.Reprod. Biol. Endocrinol. 2014; 12: 54Crossref PubMed Scopus (109) Google Scholar, Ergin et al, 2014Ergin E.G. Calişkan E. Yalçinkaya E. Oztel Z. Cökelez K. Ozay A. Ozörnek H.M. Frequency of embryo multinucleation detected by time-lapse system and its impact on pregnancy outcome.Fertil. Steril. 2014; 102: 1029-1033Abstract Full Text Full Text PDF PubMed Scopus (46) Google Scholar, Hardarson et al, 2001Hardarson T. Hanson C. Sjögren A. Lundin K. Human embryos with unevenly sized blastomeres have lower pregnancy and implantation rates: indications for aneuploidy and multinucleation.Hum. Reprod. 2001; 16: 313-318Crossref PubMed Scopus (282) Google Scholar, Hardarson et al, 2002Hardarson T. Löfman C. Coull G. Sjögren A. Hamberger L. Edwards R.G. Internalization of cellular fragments in a human embryo: time-lapse recordings.Reprod. Biomed. Online. 2002; 5: 36-38Abstract Full Text PDF PubMed Scopus (72) Google Scholar, Montag et al, 2011Montag M. Liebenthron J. Köster M. Which morphological scoring system is relevant in human embryo development?.Placenta. 2011; 32: S252-S256Abstract Full Text Full Text PDF PubMed Scopus (91) Google Scholar, Yakin et al, 2005Yakin K. Balaban B. Urman B. Impact of the presence of one or more multinucleated blastomeres on the developmental potential of the embryo to the blastocyst stage.Fertil. Steril. 2005; 83: 243-245Abstract Full Text Full Text PDF PubMed Scopus (36) Google Scholar). Moreover, abnormal cleavage patterns such as reverse or tripolar cleavage, which may affect negatively an embryo's chance to implant and develop normally, can only be assessed with TL (Ajduk et al, 2011Ajduk A. Ilozue T. Windsor S. Yu Y. Seres K.B. Bomphrey R.J. Tom B.D. Swann K. Thomas A. Graham C. Zernicka-Goetz M. Rhythmic actomyosin-driven contractions induced by sperm entry predict mammalian embryo viability.Nat. Commun. 2011; 2: 417Crossref PubMed Scopus (79) Google Scholar, Hlinka et al, 2012Hlinka D. Lazarovská S. Rutarová J. Pichlerová M. Rezácová J. Dudás M. [Non-invasive monitoring of the timing of early embryo cleavages–objectively measurable predictor of human embryo viability].Ceska Gynekol. 2012; 77: 52-57PubMed Google Scholar, Liu et al, 2014Liu Y. Chapple V. Roberts P. Matson P. Prevalence, consequence, and significance of reverse cleavage by human embryos viewed with the use of the Embryoscope time-lapse video system.Fertil. Steril. 2014; 102: 1295-1300Abstract Full Text Full Text PDF PubMed Scopus (109) Google Scholar, Meseguer et al, 2011Meseguer M. Herrero J. Tejera A. Hilligsøe K.M. Ramsing N.B. Remohí J. The use of morphokinetics as a predictor of embryo implantation.Hum. Reprod. 2011; 26: 2658-2671Crossref PubMed Scopus (614) Google Scholar, Mio, Maeda, 2008Mio Y. Maeda K. Time-lapse cinematography of dynamic changes occurring during in vitro development of human embryos.Am. J. Obstet. Gynecol. 2008; 199 (e1–e5): 660Abstract Full Text Full Text PDF PubMed Scopus (124) Google Scholar, Rubio et al, 2012Rubio I. Kuhlmann R. Agerholm I. Kirk J. Herrero J. Escribá M.J. Bellver J. Meseguer M. Limited implantation success of direct-cleaved human zygotes: a time-lapse study.Fertil. Steril. 2012; 98: 1458-1463Abstract Full Text Full Text PDF PubMed Scopus (221) Google Scholar). Additionally, TL allows assessment of the timing of cleavage, which potentially provides more information to support the decision about which embryo to transfer. It is essential to distinguish time-lapse monitoring systems (TLMS) that include integrated software for automatic tracking of cell divisions from others. To date there is only one type of device with software available that offers such complete automatic tracking and would fulfill the criteria for studies as suggested by Armstrong et al, 2015Armstrong S. Arroll N. Cree L.M. Jordan V. Farquhar C. Time-lapse systems for embryo incubation and assessment in assisted reproduction.Cochrane Database Syst. Rev. 2015; (CD011320)https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD011320.pub2Crossref Scopus (95) Google Scholar, Armstrong et al, 2018Armstrong S. Bhide P. Jordan V. Pacey A. Farquhar C. Time-lapse systems for ART.Reprod. Biomed. Online. 2018; 36: 288-289Abstract Full Text Full Text PDF PubMed Scopus (7) Google Scholar. None of the studies included in our meta-analysis or in the first Cochrane report on TL (Armstrong et al, 2015Armstrong S. Arroll N. Cree L.M. Jordan V. Farquhar C. Time-lapse systems for embryo incubation and assessment in assisted reproduction.Cochrane Database Syst. Rev. 2015; (CD011320)https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD011320.pub2Crossref Scopus (95) Google Scholar) have such software. This is a pitfall of the Armstrong study design definitions, as this would restrict TL randomized controlled trials (RCT) to only one device. This problem was highlighted as a comment to Cochrane by two authors of the present meta-analysis (CP and MM) at the time Cochrane published this first report. The commentary is publically available at the end of the Cochrane report. For the studies included in our meta-analysis, all TLMS allow tracking of cell divisions by the user (so-called annotations). On this basis, all RCT have been performed by using visual information provided through TL by scrolling back and forth through the sequence of images to have a more accurate time assessment of morphological events and therefore, rate of development. The instrument and software used by Kahraman et al, 2013Kahraman S. Cetinkaya M. Pirkevi C. Yelke H. Kumtepe Y. Comparison of blastocyst development and cycle outcome in patients with eSET using either conventional or time lapse incubators. A prospective study of good prognosis patients.J. Reprod. Stem. Cell. Biotechnol. 2013; 3: 55-61Crossref Google Scholar is exactly the same as that used by Goodman et al, 2016Goodman L.R. Goldberg J. Falcone T. Austin C. Desai N. Does the addition of time-lapse morphokinetics in the selection of embryos for transfer improve pregnancy rates? A randomized controlled trial.Fertil. Steril. 2016; 105: 275-285Abstract Full Text Full Text PDF PubMed Scopus (120) Google Scholar. Kahraman et al. explicitly mention in the Materials and Methods section that a hierarchical model proposed by Meseguer was used (Meseguer et al, 2011Meseguer M. Herrero J. Tejera A. Hilligsøe K.M. Ramsing N.B. Remohí J. The use of morphokinetics as a predictor of embryo implantation.Hum. Reprod. 2011; 26: 2658-2671Crossref PubMed Scopus (614) Google Scholar). To quote from the manuscript (p.57.): ‘For the time-lapse system a single blastocyst was selected for transfer; first, according to its morphology, and second, according to the hierarchical model recently described (Meseguer et al, 2011Meseguer M. Herrero J. Tejera A. Hilligsøe K.M. Ramsing N.B. Remohí J. The use of morphokinetics as a predictor of embryo implantation.Hum. Reprod. 2011; 26: 2658-2671Crossref PubMed Scopus (614) Google Scholar).’ This model uses time-lapse parameters that are based on kinetics rather than still images and it can either be run in the TLS by using the software function to compare and select embryos, or it can be run by an external analysis of the parameters of the model. The model used by Kahraman et al. is exactly the same model used in the study by Rubio et al. In view of this, the study by Kahraman et al. is a Type 3 study according to the definition set out by the Cochrane group. In our analysis, we focused only on studies that used TL in the study group for both undisturbed culture and for embryo evaluation and selection. This is why we excluded the two RCT of Park et al, 2015Park H. Bergh C. Selleskog U. Thurin-Kjellberg A. Lundin K. No benefit of culturing embryos in a closed system compared with a conventional incubator in terms of number of good quality embryos: results from an RCT.Hum. Reprod. 2015; 30: 268-275Crossref PubMed Scopus (43) Google Scholar and Wu et al, 2016Wu Y.G. Lazzaroni-Tealdi E. Wang Q. Zhang L. Barad D.H. Kushnir V.A. Darmon S.K. Albertini D.F. Gleicher N. Different effectiveness of closed embryo culture system with time-lapse imaging (EmbryoScope(TM)) in comparison to standard manual embryology in good and poor prognosis patients: a prospectively randomized pilot study.Reprod. Biol. Endocrinol. 2016; 14: 49Crossref PubMed Scopus (30) Google Scholar. Admittedly, inclusion of studies in which TL equipment was used as an incubator only, and TL information was disregarded, does lead to a different (neutral) conclusion regarding clinical impact (data not shown). But this approach was not of interest in our meta-analysis. All studies, except Goodman et al, 2016Goodman L.R. Goldberg J. Falcone T. Austin C. Desai N. Does the addition of time-lapse morphokinetics in the selection of embryos for transfer improve pregnancy rates? A randomized controlled trial.Fertil. Steril. 2016; 105: 275-285Abstract Full Text Full Text PDF PubMed Scopus (120) Google Scholar, carried considerable biases that are disclosed and discussed in our meta-analysis. We agree that the randomization performed in Siristatidis et al, 2015Siristatidis C. Komitopoulou M.A. Makris A. Sialakouma A. Botzaki M. Mastorakos G. Salamalekis G. Bettocchi S. Palmer G.A. Morphokinetic parameters of early embryo development via time lapse monitoring and their effect on embryo selection and ICSI outcomes: a prospective cohort study.J. Assist. Reprod. Genet. 2015; 32: 563-570Crossref PubMed Scopus (30) Google Scholar was not sound and we discussed this in Table 2 by judging ‘high risk bias’ for random sequence generation and for allocation concealment. We did not originally include the abstract from Insua and colleagues in our analysis, as the details were limited and the authors were in the process of submitting a full paper for peer review. The final data from Kovacs et al, 2017Kovacs P. Matyas S. Forgacs V. Sajgo A. Molnar L. Pribenszky C. Embryo Selection by Time Lapse Monitoring for Single Embryo Transfer (‘SET’).clinicaltrials.govDate: 2017Google Scholar has been published on Clinicaltrials.gov and thus are accessible in the public domain in detail, although this work has not been peer-reviewed. As with any analysis, it is more prudent to rely on published data rather than interim data or data that are uncertain based on the limited information that is accessible in a conference abstract. It is worthwhile to mention that in the meantime another RCT has been published that includes live birth data (Wu et al, 2017Wu L. Han W. Wang J. Zhang X. Liu W. Xiong S. Han S. Liu J. Gao Y. Huang G. Embryo culture using a time-lapse monitoring system improves live birth rates compared with a conventional culture system: a prospective cohort study.Hum. Fertil. (Camb.). 2017; ([Epub ahead of print])https://doi.org/10.1080/14647273.2017.1335886Crossref Scopus (11) Google Scholar). Adding the data from Insua et al, 2017Insua M.F. Cobo A.C. Larreategui Z. Ferrando M. Serra V. Meseguer M. Obstetric and perinatal outcomes of pregnancies conceived with embryos cultured in a time-lapse monitoring system.Fertil. Steril. 2017; 108: 498-504Abstract Full Text Full Text PDF PubMed Scopus (20) Google Scholar and Wu et al, 2017Wu L. Han W. Wang J. Zhang X. Liu W. Xiong S. Han S. Liu J. Gao Y. Huang G. Embryo culture using a time-lapse monitoring system improves live birth rates compared with a conventional culture system: a prospective cohort study.Hum. Fertil. (Camb.). 2017; ([Epub ahead of print])https://doi.org/10.1080/14647273.2017.1335886Crossref Scopus (11) Google Scholar to our meta-analysis on live birth rate (LBR) actually further strengthens our conclusions regarding the positive effect of TL on live birth (OR: 1.56; CI = 1.30–1.88; P < 0.001; based on 1945 cases, intention-to-treat analysis; see forest plot,Figure 1.). The topic of reporting early pregnancy loss, stillbirth and miscarriage per woman who became pregnant is an ongoing discussion in the scientific field. We take a point of view that is centered on the daily clinical routine rather than an academic point of view. The intention-to-treat approach is clearly important for the primary outcome of our analysis, which was ongoing pregnancy rate and live birth rate. However, early pregnancy loss, miscarriage, and stillbirth are events that can only occur once a pregnancy has been initiated. From a practical point of view as well as from a patient perspective, relating these events to the number of patients that were recruited for a study is meaningless and of no help in clinical consultation of patients who would want to know their chances of loss once they have become pregnant. As it is disclosed in the paper, CP also works for Vitrolife besides his academic employment, AMN is an employee of Vitrolife Research department and MM acts as a consultant to Vitrolife. This disclosure may affect how readers judge the conclusions of the meta-analysis and indeed that is for readers to decide themselves. On the other hand, we think it is important to mention that the authors' associations are with the research department of Vitrolife, which is dedicated to exploring the true value of interventions, with a public code-of-conduct stating the ‘policy to provide accurate, relevant information …’ and requiring that ‘…sound business ethics must always prevail’. We might mention also that the involvement of the authors with industry may provide the benefit of better insight into the actual working mode of TLMS, which becomes apparent in the discussion on the cell-tracking feature and study design arguments. Thus, we believe that an approach combining synergies between those who have differing points of view on study design and evaluation would be beneficial for the general discussion. In summary, we agree that more and better-designed studies are needed to reveal the actual value of TL intervention. We believe that only studies that use TL according to its full capacity, as defined above, have the potential to show the clinical value of this relatively new intervention. To date, a growing number of such RCT show a significant benefit of using TL. Time-lapse systems for ARTReproductive BioMedicine OnlineVol. 36Issue 3PreviewAs the authors of a Cochrane systematic review on time-lapse systems for ART, we are writing to raise a number of concerns about the robustness of a systematic review on this topic published recently in RBMOnline (Pribenszky et al., 2017). Full-Text PDF Response from the Editors: time-lapse systems for ART – meta-analyses and the issue of biasReproductive BioMedicine OnlineVol. 36Issue 3PreviewWe recently published a meta-analysis on the use of time-lapse microscopy (TLM), the conclusion of which was that the full integration of this technology in the IVF laboratory leads to better clinical outcomes (Pribenszky et al., 2017). The analysis is now being challenged by Armstrong et al. (2018) based primarily on study inclusion/exclusion criteria as well as the conflict of interest declared by the authors due to their affiliation with a manufacturer of time-lapse incubators. We invited Pribenzsky and colleagues to respond and, for the most part, we will leave their response to stand on its own (Pribenszky et al., 2018), except to add the following thoughts: Full-Text PDF
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Pribenszky et al. (2018) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: