Key result
Transvenous biventricular defibrillation was safe and feasible in 24 ICD patients, but mean defibrillation thresholds were not different from standard right ventricular systems.
Why the study?
Some ICD patients have high defibrillation thresholds due to weak shock field intensity on the left ventricle, and animal studies showed LV shocking electrodes can lower DFTs.
Does transvenous biventricular defibrillation reduce defibrillation thresholds compared to a standard right ventricular defibrillation system in patients receiving an ICD?
RCT (n=24)
anterior or posterior LV vein
Does transvenous biventricular defibrillation reduce defibrillation thresholds compared to a standard right ventricular defibrillation system in patients receiving an ICD?
Transvenous biventricular defibrillation is safe and feasible, but did not significantly reduce mean defibrillation thresholds compared to standard RV systems in this initial human experience.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Supports further testing of LV venous defibrillation in high-DFT ICD patients; leaves open clinical utility pending randomized trials.
This study investigated the safety and feasibility of transvenous biventricular defibrillation in ICD patients. Some patients may have high DFTs due to weak shock field intensity on the LV. Animal studies showed a LV shocking electrode dramatically lowered DFTs. This approach might benefit heart failure patients already receiving a LV lead or conventional ICD patients with high DFTs. A modified guidewire was used as a temporary left venous access defibrillation electrode (LVA lead). In 24 patients receiving an ICD, the LVA lead was advanced through a guide catheter in the coronary sinus (CS) and into a randomized LV vein (anterior or posterior) using a venogram for guidance. Paired DFT testing compared a standard right ventricular defibrillation system to a biventricular defibrillation system. There were no complications or adverse events. As randomized, LVA lead insertion success was 87% and 71% for anterior and posterior veins, respectively, and 100% after crossover. Total insertion process time included venogram time (32.5 +/- 26.9 minutes, range 5-115, mode 15 minutes) and LVA lead insertion time (15 +/- 14 minutes, range 1-51, mode 7 minutes). An apical LVA lead position was achieved in 11 (45%) of 24 patients and 7 (64 %) of these 11 displayed a DFT reduction; however, mean DFTs were not statistically different. Transvenous biventricular defibrillation is feasible and was safe under the conditions tested. Additional clinical studies are justified to determine if optimized LV lead designs, lead placement, and shock configurations can yield the same large DFT reductions as observed in animals.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Butter et al. (2002) conducted an RCT in ICD patients (n=24). Biventricular defibrillation system vs. Standard right ventricular defibrillation system was evaluated on Mean defibrillation threshold (DFT). Transvenous biventricular defibrillation was safe and feasible in 24 ICD patients, but mean defibrillation thresholds were not different from standard right ventricular systems.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: