Key result
A scoping review of 24 studies found that 83.3% used quantitative cross-sectional designs, with 95% focusing narrowly on eating disorders and disordered eating prevalence in elite female athletes.
The literature on elite female athletes' mental health is heavily skewed towards quantitative studies of eating disorders in USA collegiate athletes, highlighting a need for methodological diversity and broader research scopes.
Limits clinical inferences on elite female athletes' mental health; leaves open need for methodological diversity and broader research scopes.
Objectives This article examines the current state of literature focusing exclusively on mental health and mental illness of elite female athletes. The scoping review aimed to (1) identify the methodology used in this research (2) explore the use of theory in these studies, and (3) provide an overview of the research purposes to identify gaps in the literature and provide recommendations for future research. Design Scoping Review. Method Following the methodological framework by Arksey and O'Malley (2005), four databases were searched for studies that fulfilled the inclusion criteria. Following the identification of studies using broad search criteria, specific exclusion criteria were applied. Results Twenty-four studies met the review criteria, of which twenty studies (83.3%) used quantitative methods and a cross-sectional research design. Of these studies, 95% focused on eating disorders and/or disordered eating with the majority of these studies focused on identifying prevelance rates in elite female athletes who compete in 'lean-physique' or endurance sports (e.g. gymnastics, running). The restricted sample population of USA collegiate athletes, overreliance on quantitative methods, and heavy focus on eating disorder prevalence rates demonstrates an ongoing need for sport scholars to expand their research samples, methods, and aims. Conclusion Findings highlight the need for greater methodological diversity to advance our conceptual and theoretical understanding of elite female athletes' experiences of mental health and mental illness beyond numeric interpretations. Future research is needed to explore mental health in elite female athlete populations beyond ‘lean-physique’ athletes.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Perry et al. (2021) conducted a review in Mental health and mental illness (n=24). Elite sports participation was evaluated on Methodology, use of theory, and research purposes in studies of mental health in elite female athletes. A scoping review of 24 studies found that 83.3% used quantitative cross-sectional designs, with 95% focusing narrowly on eating disorders and disordered eating prevalence in elite female athletes.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: