Key result
Administering different total fluid volumes prevents firm conclusions regarding the effect of fluid type on hemodynamics.
Why the study?
Does 500 mL saline plus 500 mL hydroxyethyl starch compared to 500 mL saline alone affect hemodynamics in elderly patients before spinal anesthesia?
Does 500 mL saline plus 500 mL hydroxyethyl starch compared to 500 mL saline alone affect hemodynamics in elderly patients before spinal anesthesia?
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This letter highlights a critical methodological flaw in a prior study comparing fluid types before spinal anesthesia, noting that unequal total fluid volumes confound the hemodynamic outcomes.
To the Editor: In the recent article by Riesmeier et al.1 studying the effect of different types of fluid on hemodynamic in elderly patients before instituting spinal anesthesia, an important defect in the study design is that the subjects received different amounts of fluid (500 mL saline vs 500 mL saline plus 500 mL hydroxyethyl starch). Although the authors mention this as a limitation that may in and of itself influence the primary end point (hemodynamic changes), the practical effect of this limitation is that no firm conclusions can be made in terms of type of fluid and its effects on hemodynamics. In other words, to study the efficacy of preload volume and compare the effects of crystalloid/colloid versus crystalloid administration before spinal anesthesia on cardiac output and blood pressure, both groups should receive the same total amount of fluids. Ates Duman, MD Department of Anesthesiology Selcuk University Hospital Konya, Turkey [email protected]
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Duman et al. (2009) conducted a letter in Patients undergoing transurethral resection of the prostate / spinal anesthesia. Saline plus hydroxyethyl starch vs. 500 mL saline was evaluated on Hemodynamic changes (cardiac output and blood pressure). Administering different total fluid volumes prevents firm conclusions regarding the effect of fluid type on hemodynamics.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: