Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Perirectal disease, in conjunction with inflammatory bowel disease (IBD), can be extremely difficult to manage either medically or surgically and can be debilitating for the patient. Both medical and surgical treatments should be considered depending on the type and extent of the perianal disease. The following will be a very brief outline of an approach to the diagnostic procedures to be considered, as well as the management of each of the following conditions. Septic disease around the anus, particularly in association with Crohn's disease (CD), can be painful and bothersome to the patient, or can look bothersome but actually produce little in the way of symptoms. The approach to management should be very dependent on the symptoms that are produced by these problems, but usually it will require both a medical and a surgical approach. Initially, it is important to make the diagnosis by knowing the anatomy around the anus, as well as the extent of the presenting disease. In my experience, it is difficult to determine the exact extent of the disease in one's office. Therefore, it is my recommendation that in fistulous disease, and in particular in complex fistulous disease, examination under anaesthesia is part of the examination process. It is only with this type of manipulation that one can absolutely determine whether or not a fistulotomy can be performed. In the majority of CD patients, fistulas are rather complex and do not lend themselves easily to fistulotomy. Fistulograms, of course, can be performed; however, they are difficult to interpret. Depending on the individual ultrasonographer, transanal ultrasonography can be used to determine the extent of fistulous tract. I personally use this modality when I cannot absolutely define the extent of the problem, or find an internal opening at the time of examination under anaesthesia. However, this is a rather rare occurrence and does not therefore warrant doing transanal ultrasonography on all IBD patients with fistulous tracts. In some instances, it has been shown that magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is a beneficial diagnostic procedure in delineating the various tracts in complex perianal disease. Again, I do not feel that a routine MRI is warranted in this type of problem, both because of its cost and the limited added benefit that it might provide over an examination under anaesthesia. The approach to these problems is usually a combined medical and surgical one. However, one only knows what combination of management to utilize after one determines the exact extent of the problem. It has been demonstrated that a simple intersphincteric fistula can be managed very well with a fistulotomy without producing incontinence. Obviously if the patient is symptomatic from gastrointestinal disease, and in particular diarrhea from colonic disease, then it is important to place the patient on some form of medical therapy to control the disease. If the disease is not well controlled, then more minor interferences or disruptions of the anal sphincter during a fistulotomy may produce incontinence. This is an issue that must be seriously considered before undertaking any type of surgical procedure. The healing rate has been shown to be the same as in a normal patient with a simple fistula. The recurrence rate is obviously higher in patients with CD, but the recurrence may be at a site other than the original fistulous site. Therefore, in summary, for a simple, low-lying, intersphincteric fistula-in-ano in association with IBD, the approach to this should be mainly a surgical one. Complex fistulae are quite common in association with CD. These can range from transsphincteric fistulae to horseshoe-type fistulae, both of which will require local limited surgery along with intensive medical therapy. From a surgical point of view, it is important to rid the patient of any ongoing sepsis. Again it is our practice to place the patient under an anaesthetic to not only document the extent of the disease and the anatomy of the various tracts involved, but also to reveal external openings to allow for drainage of any pus, and to allow for continuing drainage of these difficult fistulae. Medically the patient is then placed on a combination of metronidazole and ciprofloxacin, which have been shown in nonrandomized studies to be of benefit in perianal CD. We would not initially place a patient on imuran or immunosuppressive agents. With persisting disease, imuran, cyclosporine, and anti-tumor necrosis factor (TNF)-alpha may be used in conjunction with surgical therapy. Another reason to examine these patients initially is to curette the fistulous tract. Occasionally with chronic fistulae, histologic examinatin of the curettings may reveal a primary or secondary carcinoma in a fistulous tract. The only way that this can be diagnosed is to obtain tissue for pathological assessment. Therefore I would reiterate the importance of a combined medical/surgical approach for these complex problems. In certain circumstances, particularly in those where multiple fistulae have occurred, it is important not to cut through any significant amount of sphincter muscle. Therefore, a surgical opening may be made in the external portion of the fistulous tract up to but not including the muscle portion. A loose seton can then be used around the remaining fistula to allow for drainage and to prevent pocketing of pus. This is a temporizing maneuver and obviously will not allow for complete healing of the fistulous tract. If all forms of medical and local surgical treatment fail, then one may have to consider further surgical intervention. Factors that influence further surgery are the extent and the symptomatology produced by the gastrointestinal disease, as well as the quality of life that the patient is experiencing with their perirectal disease. A defunctioning loop ileostomy can be offered as an option to the patient. On a temporary basis, it has been shown that there can be significant improvement in a large percentage of patients with perirectal disease when they are defunctioned proximally. However, there is certainly no guarantee that this will allow for healing in the long term, and there may actually be an exacerbation of the disease in the colon, rectum, and anus even when the patient is defunctioned. However, defunctioning the patient with severe perianal disease does allow for an opportunity for the patient to psychologically adapt to a stoma, which they may have on a more permanent basis in later life. It also allows for some healing and minimization of the septic process in the perirectal area if one is considering going forward with a proctectomy. For patients with very severe medically resistant disease in the perirectal area, proctectomy may be their only option for an improved quality of life. It is important to try to minimize the septic process around the anus before undertaking a proctectomy. If one is forced to do a proctectomy in the presence of overt sepsis, then infection in the perineal wound will be a greater risk; if an infection does occur it leads to significant morbidity. Therefore, I stress the importance of minimizing the septic process before undertaking this radical form of therapy. It is difficult to explain and comprehend the nuances of the management of patients with severe perirectal disease. Each of the patients has to be individualized, as each has different priorities in their lives. However, having said that, the most important aspect of their care is the combined medical and surgical approach to their problem. This can be a particularly perplexing problem in IBD patients. Fissures in general are very painful. Combined with a diarrheal type of disease, the problem can be almost unbearable for the patient. Diagnosis again is not often easy because the patient will often not allow the physician to adequately examine the region in view of the amount of pain that it causes. Fissures in association with IBD do not always occur in the usual 6 and 12 o'clock positions. They can occur anywhere around the anus and are often more indolent and deeply penetrating than the usual fissure. In these cases we try to avoid usual surgical intervention if possible. Initially, again, it is important to control the intralumenal disease. Just affecting and minimizing the amount of diarrhea may in fact improve the patient's quality of life. We will often use local anaesthetic ointments such as 5% xylocaine, along with steroid or 5-ASA suppositories, depending on whether or not the patient's pain tolerance allows them to insert a suppository within the anal area. Local ointments and creams can be used, but if unsuccessful, we will then place the patient on 0.5%-1% nitro paste applied anally. This has the function of relaxing the anal sphincter and improving the patient's symptoms. One must be cautious of headaches that occur quite frequently with the use of nitro paste. We have had no experience with botulinum toxin nor with hyperbaric oxygenation for either fissure or fistulous disease. The use of ciprofloxacin and flagyl with this type of problem is not usually beneficial, and I have not seen any other anti-CD medication that is successful in managing this type of problem. In conventional type of fissures in ano, if the above stated measures failed, we would do a lateral internal sphincterotomy, which is a very successful procedure in curing fissures. However, in IBD patients, or in any diarrheal disease patient, we would try to avoid doing a sphincterotomy. We might consider taking the patient to the operating room and, under anaesthesia, dilating the sphincter muscle and/or performing an internal sphincterotomy, only half-way up to the dentate line. However, I believe that one should be extremely cautious in doing any type of sphincterotomy in an IBD patient. Internal haemorrhoids in association with fissures in IBD are another difficult problem. We would not recommend rubber-banding for this type of problem as it only exacerbates the underlying sphincter spasm and causes worsening of the anal pain. I will only address the situation of external edematous hemorrhoids or skin tags in association with IBD. These are particularly common in patients with CD but also occur in patients with ulcerative colitis (UC). They are often a manifestation of the extreme irritation caused by the persisting diarrhea in these conditions. However, one should be very cautious about treating these on a surgical basis. It has been shown that the rate of healing in excised external hemorrhoids or enlarged skin tags is quite poor in those patients who have CD and UC. Therefore, more conservative measures of treatment should be undertaken in the form of local ointment. Those with a steroid base should be used sparingly in order to avoid thinning of the skin in that region. Our own preference for managing edematous external tags is to use 10% magnesium and phenol lotion. This has an extremely soothing effect, and the phenol will cause evaporation of the edema within the skin tag. In our experience this has been a very successful form of therapy. The management of perirectal disease in association with IBD requires an individual approach to the patient with combined medical and surgical therapy where appropriate. No matter what therapy is used, the main goal is to alleviate symptoms and cure the problem where possible. Before undertaking management it is crucial to delineate the extent not only of the local disease but the total extent of the problem in the gastrointestinal tract. This will obviously influence the way in which the local disease is managed. What has been presented is a practical, common-sense approach to the management of what is often an extremely difficult problem.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Zane Cohen (2007) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: