Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Wilmes et al. recently reported in The Lancet Regional Health À Europe that asymptomatic index cases (AIC) play an important role in the transmission and spread of SARS-CoV2 infections [1].Secondary attack rates of 283 AIC were significant (0.02) but lower than those of the 567 symptomatic index cases (SIC; 0.04).AIC infected on average 0.6 contacts, only slightly less than SIC (0.7 contacts).Higher values but similar differences were found within households.These results are in line with 13 other studies including 111 AIC, reviewed in a recent meta-analysis [2].Transmission rates of AIC ranged from 0À2.2% compared to 0.8À15.4% for SIC [2].Another meta-analysis found that household transmission from AIC was 0À4.9% compared to 18.0%; for SIC [3].In another household study, AIC were four times less likely to pass the virus to a household contact, but ultimately caused one fifth of household infections [4].All of these studies agree that AIC transmit SARS-COV2 to contacts, although to a somewhat lesser extent than SIC.However, a large study from post-lockdown Wuhan came to a very different conclusion [5].After 11 weeks, the total lockdown was lifted by April 8th, 2020.Between April 8th and May 10th only 6 new COVID19 cases were confirmed.Four days later (May 14th), the city embarked on a comprehensive 19-days screening effort including 92% of its residents irrespective of their COVID19-status.Among 34.424 recovered COVID19 patients, 107 tested positive, corresponding to 310 per 100.000patients.Among those without COVID19 history, there were no new symptomatic cases detected, but 300 asymptomatic PCR-positive cases (3 per 100.000).The 1.174 close contacts of these AIC were all PCR-negative and none became positive during isolation.The authors concluded that asymptomatic PCR-positive individuals do not transmit the virus to others [5].How can this apparent disparity be reconciled?Several lines of evidence suggest that the epidemiological context in Wuhan was very different from the one in Luxembourg and most other studies.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Claude P. Muller (2021) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: