Key result
Cuffless pulse wave BP estimators lack sufficient validity for clinical use despite person-specific calibration.
Why the study?
Does cuffless blood pressure monitoring using pulse wave travel times accurately estimate systolic and diastolic blood pressure compared to cuff-based measurements in healthy adults?
Observational (n=41)
No
Does cuffless blood pressure monitoring using pulse wave travel times accurately estimate systolic and diastolic blood pressure compared to cuff-based measurements in healthy adults?
Cuffless blood pressure monitoring using pulse wave travel times shows high reliability but insufficient validity for clinical or stress research use, even with person-specific calibration.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Cuffless PWTT BP estimators should not enter clinical use; leaves open need for prospective validation beyond person-specific calibration.
PURPOSE: Continuous, non-invasive blood pressure (BP) monitoring is essential for understanding cardiovascular dynamics in real-world settings. This study evaluated the reliability and validity of a cuffless method for ambulatory BP monitoring using pulse wave travel times derived from bio-impedance, impedance cardiography, and electrocardiography. We examined whether this method can accurately estimate systolic and diastolic BP cross varying conditions. METHODS: Forty-one young, healthy participants completed a protocol involving postural changes, physical activity, and mental stress tasks. Pulse arrival time (PAT) and pulse transit time (PTT) were extracted, and person-specific models estimated BP using (1) all data of the person ('double-dipping') - used in most previous studies -, (2) half of a person's data (calibration), or (3) person-invariant parameters (calibration-free) which would enhance practical utility. Cuff-based BP served as the reference. Test-retest reliability, and construct and convergent validity were assessed. RESULTS: Test-retest reliability was high for PAT- and PTT-based BP for all approaches (ICC > 0.7), comparable to cuff-based measurements. Construct validity was generally poor: BP changes during physical activity were detected, but responses to mental stressors were not. Only double-dipping showed acceptable convergent validity, likely reflecting overfitting. In the calibration approach, convergence with cuff-based BP was moderate (MAE = 10.1-12.9 mmHg), with 59.2-68.5% of estimates within 10 mmHg of reference values. The strongest deterioration of convergentvalidity occurred with person-invariant models. CONCLUSION: Although cuffless pulse wave travel time-based BP estimators showed strong reliability, validity was insufficient for clinical or stress research use, even with person-specific calibration. Future work should explore extended calibrationperiods before testing in naturalistic settings.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Schoenmakers et al. (2026) conducted an observational in Healthy (n=41). Cuffless ambulatory blood pressure monitoring (pulse wave travel times) vs. Cuff-based blood pressure monitoring was evaluated on Convergent validity (Mean Absolute Error) and estimation accuracy within 10 mmHg of reference values (MAE 10.1-12.9 mmHg). Cuffless pulse wave travel time-based blood pressure estimators showed strong test-retest reliability but insufficient convergent validity for clinical use, even with person-specific calibration.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: