Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Diversity management holds a central place in human resource management theory and practice, where it refers to the organizational handling of individual and group differences together with the structural inequality, normatively loaded discourses and legal conditions attached to it. Approaches vary in their objectives, ranging from affirmative action and human resource strategy to controlling, policy making, and marketing; and they vary in direction between a business case and a justice case. This conceptual breadth produces ambivalent effects, contradictory findings, and limited knowledge about what such practices mean for the people who work under them. Drawing on a qualitative design, this study reconstructs the meaning of diversity management from the first-person perspective. The analysis relies on forty-five in-depth interviews with stakeholders across hierarchical levels and career stages from different types and sizes of organizations. The findings show how diversity management appears either as an alienating practice drained of meaning or as a threat, and it is understood by participants to sustain the inequalities it addresses. Between the status groups, negatively biased mental representations, attribution and projection, externalization and defensiveness solidify the reverse outcomes, building up to a negative circuit; diversity management then settles into a unitarist logic that subordinates its normative objective to economic interest and undermines its original goal. The findings support a radical reassessment of current approaches, and argue for integrative and contextualized perspectives, new theorizing, and structural change.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Degen et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: