Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
PLANT the best, save the rest.” This familiar idea has acquired new legal meaning as a result of the sod-buster, swampbuster, and conservation reserve provisions of the 1985 Food Security Act. Identifying the best land is, unfortunately, an unfinished task. Important criteria include productivity, workability, erodibility, accessibility, contiguity, and management history. A look at only the first of these factors allows one to evaluate the potential usefulness of some common procedures for ranking soils according to their “innate productivity.” A good (reliable and easy to determine) index of soil productivity clearly would be useful for many groups of people: landowners deciding how to use their land; tax assessors appraising rural property ( 2, 16 ); municipalities zoning land to influence its use ( 22 ); planners aligning utility corridors ( 4, 15 ); foresters and wildlife biologists trying to evaluate sustainable yield ( 3, 17 ); the U.S. Department of Agriculture targeting regions for price supports, conservation practices, or land-retirement programs ( 1, 21 ); rural sociologists and others trying to designate prime farmland for protection of a way of life ( 19 ); financiers assessing the feasibility of development projects ( 18 ); and soil scientists trying to provide accurate information to all of the above groups ( 5, 10, 20 ). …
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Gersmehl et al. (1990) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: