Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The idea that cancer and tuberculosis are antagonistic diseases was introduced into medical literature chiefly by Rokitansky (3855) (1) who stressed the infrequent association of the two diseases in the same individual and the rarity of their coexistence in the same organ. Rokitansky noted also that cyst formation, typhoid fever, goiter, rickets and some other diseases were seldom found associated with tuberculosis. The problem has attracted some attention from time to time and has been given renewed interest by Pearl9s recent publication. It is unnecessary for us to give a detailed account of the previous work on this subject since the literature has been extensively reviewed by Pearl (2). The publications fall into three groups: (a) ease reports; (b) experimental studies; and ( c ) statistical studies. The case reports deal largely with descriptions of cancer and tuberculosis in the same individual or in the same organ. Evidence of this kind is valuable in showing that one disease does not always exclude the other, but it does not prove that there is no antagonism between them. The experimental method was employed by Centanni and Ilezzesi (3) in 1926. They used a strain of mice that were highly resistant to the tubercle bacillus. The tumor used was a transplantable adenocarcinoma that developed in nearly 100 per cent of animals inoculated. An emulsion containing both carcinoma cells and tubercle bacilli gave no tumors when injected into the mice. When tuberculin was substituted for the tubercle bacilli in the emulsion the growth of the tumor was retarded but not prevented. Injection of tubercle bacilli directly into the tumor destroyed it partly. Dead bacilli had no effect upon the cancer. When cancer cells and tubercle bacilli were injected simultaneously into different parts of the body, there was a temporary or permanent depression in the rate of growth of the cancer. When cancer cells were injected into animals that had been previously infected with tuberculosis the growth of the tumor was delayed.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
E. T. Bell (1929) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: