This is the authors' abstract. We don't add key points for this paper.
Sir—Campylobacter species, particularly those other than Campylobacter jejuni and Campylobacter coli, are frequently underidentified in isolates from clinical specimens. We read with interest the recent report of Labarca et al. [1] that compared the frequency of recovery among 5 Los Angeles County clinical laboratories of Campylobacter species from stool specimens obtained from patients with campylobacteriosis. We agree with Labarca et al. [1] that Campylobacter upsaliensis is often underidentified and that the true prevalence of infection with this pathogen is unknown. As Labarca et al. [1] suggested, the failure of 1 of the 5 participating laboratories to isolate C. upsaliensis may have been due to the culture medium used and the shorter incubation time, which are critical factors because C. upsaliensis strains are generally more fastidious and slower growing than are C. jejuni strains. However, we also note that this laboratory used Campy-thioglycolate broth (Becton Dickinson) as a transport medium and that this broth contains cephalothin [1], to which C. upsaliensis has been shown to be susceptible [2]. Incubation conditions in this laboratory were not specified and may not have been optimal for efficient growth of some Campylobacter species [3]. Also, 4 of the 5 participating laboratories in the study used isolation and incubation temperatures of 42°C (3 laboratories) or 38°C (1 laboratory), which may be too high for growing some strains of C. upsaliensis and other Campylobacter species. Our laboratory does not use selective media for Campylobacter isolation but, rather, uses the “Cape Town” protocol of membrane filtration (pore diameter, 0.60 μm) onto antibiotic-free Tryptose blood agar plates (CM 233; Oxoid), with primary incubation at 37°C in an H2-enriched microaerobic atmosphere (BR38 [Oxoid] or BBL70304 [Becton Dickinson] gaspaks, without catalyst) [3, 4]. When tested against a variety of selective media, this protocol was consistently superior for isolating 17 species or subspecies of Campylobacteraceae from clinical specimens [3, 4]. The use of antibiotic-free plates allows growth of antibiotic-susceptible strains of C. upsaliensis and other Campylobacter species. The H2-enriched microaerobic atmosphere permits growth of species that have an essential requirement for H2, such as Campylobacter concisus. Some strains of C. fetus subsp fetus, C. lari, and C. upsaliensis grow poorly, if at all, under conventional microaerobic conditions but flourish in an H2-enhanced microaerobic atmosphere [4]. Since 1990, we have isolated >4000 strains of Campylobacter, Helicobacter, and Arcobacter species from cultures of diarrhetic stool specimens and blood samples obtained from our patients [4, 5]. Nearly 1000 strains of C. upsaliensis comprised ~23% of the total number of Campylobacter isolates and, similar to the observations of Labarca et al. [1], C. upsaliensis was the second most common Campylobacter species identified, after C. jejuni [4]. Our C. upsaliensis strains have clinical and pathogenic properties similar to those of the universally acknowledged pathogen, C. jejuni [5]. The Cape Town protocol is a simple, cost effective, and efficient means to isolate fastidious species or particularly fragile strains of Campylobacteraceae. We suggest that use of this protocol in future Los Angeles County–area studies will improve the ability to isolate Campylobacter species and provide a much better understanding of the role of all Campylobacter species that are involved in human disease in this area.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Lastovica et al. (2003) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: