Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
‘Major botanical advances often suffer the worst of fates - the scientific community ignores them until they are independently ‘discovered' or confirmed by zoologists. For example, the principles of inheritance, initially worked out in the garden pea were not generally accepted until verified in animals (Bateson 1902)'Rieseberg and Burke [2001]Recent research into various aspects of ploidy changes, gene and genome duplications encompasses an enormous spectrum of fascinating topics. New empirical insights comprise repeated polyploidization [Paterson et al., 2012] at the genomic end, and the recognition of the significance of partial gene duplications [Pennisi, 2012] at the genic end, adding to Ohno's inspiring classical hypothesis on the ‘evolution by gene and genome duplications' [Ohno, 1970; cf. Holmquist, 2000].Like most fields of modern biology [Schuster, 2008], polyploidy research experiences an ongoing transformation by next and beyond-next generation sequencing (NGS) technologies. Currently, studies on genome-wide hybridization, introgression and allopolyploidy are directed to organisms with no prior sequence data [Buggs et al., 2012a; Twyford and Ennos, 2012]. NGS-supported studies not only helped generating dense linkage maps of polyploid non-model organisms [Everett et al., 2012] but also provided genome-wide evidence for ‘genomic and transcriptomic shock' [Buggs et al., 2011], rapid and repeated gene loss in young allopolyploids [Buggs et al., 2012b] as well as changes in polyploid gene expression [Roulin et al., 2012]. Schartl et al. [2013] hypothesize that paralog retention after ancient genome duplication may have supported the high level of behavioral complexity in some teleosts. A role of small RNAs in allopolyploid and hybrid gene expression has been suggested [Ignacio et al., 2012], which generate morphological variation and hybrid vigor as well as transgressive phenotypes with potential for adaptive evolution [Ng et al., 2012]. Latest studies propose a role of cis- and trans-regulatory elements and chromatin modifications on gene expression diversity in allotetraploids [Shi et al., 2012]. Technological advances will soon also allow testing newly proposed mechanisms for gene expression in relation to cellular volume and genome size [Marguerat and Bähler, 2012]. Polyploidy is currently further studied regarding modifications of the cell cycle, biological networks, metabolic phenotypes, and in context to tumor biology [Mayfield-Jones et al., 2013]. Latest applications of research on ploidy changes include the creation of haploid mammalian pluripotent cell lines from which live transgenic mice could be produced [Li et al., 2012]. Despite its path-making character, not all the scientific progress depends on technology. Especially interactions between organisms of different ploidy levels [Bogart et al., 2007; Choleva et al., 2012], including insights from empirical population genetics in plants [Ma et al., 2010] and animals [Stöck et al., 2010], added to our understanding of the evolution of polyploid organisms. Older ideas [Ellstrand and Schierenbeck, 2000] on the ecological consequences of polyploidy, such as its potential role in facilitating biological invasions [te Beest et al., 2012] or the susceptibility to parasites [King et al., 2012], were recently re-examined.From these examples, it becomes obvious that advancement in polyploidy research often stems from studies on vascular plants. Indeed, since the famous article by Muller [1925] entitled ‘Why polyploidy is rarer in animals than in plants', polyploidy research has been usually led by botanists. While this is clearly caused by the major role of polyploidization in angiosperm evolution [Wendel, 2000; Comai, 2005], there is no doubt that ancient [e.g. van de Peer et al., 2009] as well as recent polyploidizations have significantly shaped the genomes of animals as reviewed recently [e.g. Gregory and Mable, 2005; Mable et al., 2011]. ‘Additionally, several major insights on polyploids also come from the Kingdom Fungi. Oomycetes, which are non-true fungi members, as well as brown algae (Fucales, Laminariales and diatoms) contain several examples of polyploid species. In the Alveolata group, the remarkable species Paramecium tetraurelia underwent three successive rounds of whole genome duplications and has proven of value as major model for palaeopolyploid studies. Therefore, far from being restricted to plants and animals, polyploidy is more likely a general process of eukaryotic evolution.' [cited from Albertin and Marullo, 2012].Important research questions on polyploidy were asked by Soltis et al. [2010]: ‘What is (are) the most frequent mechanism(s) of polyploidization? What factors promote/facilitate polyploidization? What factors favour autopolyploid vs. allopolyploid formation? Do multiple origins result in lineages with differing evolutionary trajectories and/or cryptic species?' Several of these questions still remain to be answered. We here would like to add and modify the question by Muller [1925]: What are the evolutionary trajectories from ancestral diploids to derived polyploids, and which role do the (homomorphic or perhaps heteromorphic?) sex chromosomes play during these evolutionary pathways to polyploidy? An interesting view comes from Ming et al. [2011]. They suggest the frequency of polyploidy to be a reason for the rarity of evolved plant sex chromosomes because the frequency of homozygous recessive alleles in 4 or 8 homologous chromosomes is much lower than in 2 homologous chromosomes. Evans et al. [2008, 2012] discuss the available evidence for sex chromosome duplication in the anuran genus Xenopus.More than 30 years ago, Lewis [1980] edited his comprehensive work on both polyploid plants and animals. Despite several calls to unite the efforts [e.g. Mable, 2003, 2004] and recent conferences trying to bring botanists and zoologists among polyploidy researchers closer together (e.g. in London, 2003; Saint-Malo, 2009; Lisbon, 2010; and Prague, 2012), the path-making research has mostly remained with plant researchers. Several themed journal issues or books have been published since [e.g. Leitch et al., 2004; Ainouche and Jenczewski, 2010; Soltis and Soltis, 2012; Mable, 2013], covering many aspects of genome evolution, mainly in plants but also in animals.Quite in parallel, starting from the Cytogenetic and Genome Research editor's invitation to assemble research advances on animal polyploidy, in light of the previous paragraphs, we considered it more innovative and fascinating to mirror and to contrast research on polyploid animals and plants. We proposed a list of apparent research hot spots and invited leading researchers in their fields to join a team of authors to meet this challenge (fig. 1). In order to achieve a comparable structure for the respective plant- or animal-specific chapters, authors were requested to initially develop a common list of subtopics to be pursued during the (separate) writing processes. Although each plant- and animal-specific part is in most cases a separate article, the idea was to let authors follow at least similar lines of content so as to produce an exciting chapter that may be useful for both, animal and plant researchers. We leave it to the readers to judge themselves to which extent this comparability among the ‘sister articles' has been accomplished by different authors. After all, we have tried our best to provide critical reviews for each contribution prior to its publication by 2 or more referees in order to meet high standards.Last but not least, we wish everyone an inspiring reading.We are grateful to the authors who endorsed this novel concept and contributed to this project. During this work, M. Stöck has been supported by a Heisenberg-Fellowship of the German Research Foundation (DFG; STO 493/2-1) and by the Leibniz-Institute of Freshwater Ecology and Inland Fisheries (IGB, Germany). D.K. Lamatsch has been supported by the Austrian Academy of Sciences and the University of Innsbruck (Austria).
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Stöck et al. (2013) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: