Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Can reason defeat right-wing populism? And what duties do ordinary citizens have when liberal democracy comes under pressure from within? In this commentary, I engage with Gabriele Badano and Alasia Nuti’s Politicizing Political Liberalism , focusing on their account of the ‘duty of pressure’: a moral duty requiring reasonable citizens to engage and seek to persuade supporters of right-wing populist parties through everyday political interactions. I argue that the book makes an important contribution by treating right-wing populism as a central challenge for political liberalism and by locating democratic self-defence not only in the state but also among ordinary citizens. Yet the account remains insufficiently political. While the duty of pressure offers a compelling normative orientation, it overestimates the capacity of reasoned persuasion to counter contemporary right-wing populism. Drawing on scholarship on populism, polarisation and political identification, I argue that right-wing populism is sustained not simply by ‘unreasonable’ beliefs but by affective attachments, social identities, media ecologies and forms of political belonging. I argue that a political liberalism adequate to the challenge of right-wing populism requires a richer sociological account of how citizens are mobilised, sorted and attached to political identities in contemporary democratic life.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Benjamin Moffitt (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: