Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Disruptive and cryptic colorationCamouflage may be achieved in three ways: crypsis, disruptive coloration and masquerade (Endler 1981).Cryptic prey resemble random samples of the visual background (Endler 1978(Endler , 1981(Endler , 1984)), minimizing their signal/noise ratio (S/N).Disruptively coloured prey contain some highly conspicuous as well as cryptic pattern elements.The conspicuous elements distract the predator's attention and break up the body outline, making detection of the prey difficult (Thayer 1909;Cott 1940; Stevens & Cuthill 2006).In masquerade, the prey is detected as distinct from the visual background but not recognized as edible (Endler 1981), for example by resembling a leaf (Thayer 1909).The two ways of avoiding detection, crypsis and disruptive coloration, appear contradictory (Merilaita & Lind 2005), because crypsis relies on minimizing the S/N, while disruptive coloration relies on keeping S/N high.This issue of Proceedings B contains two elegant papers on the interaction between disruptive coloration and crypsis (Schaefer & Stobbe 2006; Stevens et al. 2006).Following Cuthill et al. (2005), these authors constructed artificial prey with pattern elements that stimulated bird eyes in known ways (allowing visual contrast predictions), attached a mealworm to each moth-like stimulus for a reward, and presented these prey to wild birds by attaching them to tree trunks and recording disappearance.The stimuli consisted of some patches that were similar to and other patches that contrasted with the visual background.In disruptive ('edge') patterns, contrasting patches cut across the edges of the 'wings', while in the non-disruptive ('inside') patterns, the contrasting patches were away from the edges of the wings.Like Cuthill et al. (2005), the two new papers found that the disruptive pattern resulted in higher 'survivorship' (significantly lower rates of removal by the birds) than the inside pattern.These new papers go further in examining the joint effects of contrast and outline disruption on fitness.Schaefer & Stobbe (2006) presented the prey against two different visual backgrounds: birch and oak bark with moss.In the first two experiments, the brown and pink colours of the stimuli were similar to a real moth, while in the third a novel colour (blue) was used.Schaefer & Stobbe (2006) predicted that the advantage of disruptive patterns would be greater when disruptive patches had higher contrast, and that disruptive contrast with the visual background increases fitness even if it decreases crypsis.On birch, the cryptic non-disruptive form did worse than the others.On oak, the edge forms and the cryptic (brown) inside form did equally well but better than the more conspicuous pink inside form.This suggests that on some backgrounds the joint effects of disruption
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
John A. Endler (2006) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: