Key result
Kidney transplantation highlights an inverse relationship between sympathetic cardiovascular outflow and muscular arterial distensibility.
Why the study?
The study addresses the complex sympathetic influences on vascular function and kidney transplantation outcomes, highlighting gaps in understanding sympathetic–vascular interactions in renal disease.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Hypothesis-generating for sympathetic effects on muscular arteries post-transplant; leaves open whether modulation improves distensibility.
There has been a multitude of evidence collected over the years to support the concept that the sympathetic influences of renal dysfunction and renal insufficiency-related hypertension are closely linked. For example, studies performed some years ago in experimental animals showed that stimulation of mechanically and chemically sensitive renal afferents may promote a blood pressure elevation which appears to be largely mediated by an increase in efferent adrenergic neural discharge to the cardiovascular system [1–4]. Furthermore, studies in hypertensive patients with chronic renal failure demonstrated that, in the uremic state, plasma norepinephrine levels are often increased and that this increase is ascribable not only to a flow-dependent reduction in norepinephrine tissue clearance, but also, and to a major extent, to an augmented secretion of the adrenergic neurotransmitter from sympathetic nerve endings [5–7]. This has been further documented by a study employing the microneurographic approach (i.e. the only technique available allowing sympathetic neural discharge to be directly quantified in conscious humans), where the authors were able to show that central sympathetic activation usually does occur in chronic renal failure [8]. Such evidence is further supported by the intriguing finding that, in patients undergoing haemodialysis, bilateral nephrectomy may exert sympathoinhibitory effects (presumably by removing the afferent sympathoexcitatory signals arising from the failing kidneys) thereby ‘normalizing’ adrenergic cardiovascular drive and blood pressure values [8]. It is also well documented (particularly with the recent availability of high-resolution echo-tracking techniques allowing the distensibility and compliance properties of large- and medium-sized arteries to be assessed on a beat-to-beat basis) that a marked reduction in the viscoelastic properties of the arterial vessels characterizes end-stage renal disease [9,10]. In the above-mentioned scenario, the paper by Kosch et al. published in this issue of the journal [11], not only further documents the favourable effects of kidney transplantation combined with bilateral nephrectomy on sympathetic activity and arterial distensibility, but also offers two sets of new data. First, it is clearly demonstrated that, in patients with end-stage renal disease undergoing renal transplantation alone, the persistently elevated sympathetic cardiovascular outflow and the persistently reduced distensibility properties of the arterial vessels are phenomena which are closely related to each other. Second, by showing that this relationship holds true for the brachial artery but not for the carotid artery, the authors provide evidence that an heterogeneity either in the distensibility properties between muscular-type and elastic-type arteries or in the sympathetic–vascular interactions occurring in the two vascular districts takes place in this condition. These two novel findings will be discussed separately. Sympathetic modulation of arterial distensibility Several years ago, Bevan and Tsuru [12,13] elegantly demonstrated that central ear artery adrenergic denervation causes a reduction in arterial lumen diameter and cross-sectional area of the media in rabbits, thus implying that adrenergic vascular outflow exerts tonic influences on vasomotor tone as well as on the growth of the arterial vessel. Similar results have been reported for cerebral vessels [14]. Technical progress in the in-vivo assessment of the mechanical and viscoelastic properties of large- and medium-sized arteries has allowed this finding to be confirmed and expanded, providing evidence that, in Wistar–Kyoto rats, chemical sympathectomy increases arterial compliance and distensibility at the level of both carotid and femoral arteries [15]. The influence of neuroadrenergic factors on the mechanical properties of arterial vessels has also been extensively investigated in man. It has been shown that an acute increase in sympathetic tone brought about by a variety of laboratory manoeuvres, such as the cold pressor test, mental arithmetic or cigarette smoking [16–18], triggers a marked reduction in arterial compliance, even when this variable is calculated in the so-called ‘isobaric conditions', thus ruling out the effects of the blood pressure increase, elicited by the above-mentioned stimuli, on vessel distensibility. Other recent observations support the concept that adrenergic influences are of key importance in determining the contractile status of the smooth muscle arterial wall. For example, it has been shown that (i) local infusion of phenylephrine in the brachial artery at doses devoid of systemic effects markedly reduces brachial artery compliance [19] and (ii) brachial plexus anaesthesia or sympathetic gangliectomy significantly increases arterial distensibility in healthy subjects and in patients with peripheral artery disease, respectively [20]. In line with the above-mentioned observations, the paper by Kosch et al. [11] provides evidence that the sympathetic nervous system, when chronically stimulated, may adversely affect the viscoelastic properties of arterial vessels. This is because, in renal transplant recipients with marked sympathetic activation, an inverse relationship is found between the degree of adrenergic hyperactivity and the extent of arterial distensibility impairment. This means that the greater the adrenergic activation, the lower the brachial artery distensibility, suggesting that impairment of the mechanical vessel wall properties characterizing kidney transplantation may depend on the state of sympathetic overactivity. Is the phoenomenon specific for this condition or does it also occur in other pathological states characterized by an hyperadrenergic cardiovascular drive? Although the study by Kosch et al. [11] does not provide any specific information on this issue, the results from a previous study by our group permit an answer to this question. We indeed found [19] that in a condition such as congestive heart failure, known to be characterized by a marked sympathetic activation coupled with a reduction in arterial compliance [21,22], there was a close inverse relationship between muscle sympathetic nerve traffic and radial artery compliance values, thus resembling that which Kosch and coworkers describe in their renal transplant patients. It can thus be concluded that in pathological conditions other than renal failure, a ‘chronic’ increase in sympathetic cardiovascular drive exerts adverse effects on arterial distensibility. Regional heterogeneity of sympathetic-vascular influences In their study, Kosch and coworkers noticed that the inverse relationship between muscle sympathetic nerve traffic and arterial distensibility values seen at the level of the brachial artery does not apply to an elastic-type vessel, such as the carotid arttey [11]. Given the evidence that sympathectomy may exert divergent effects on femoral and aortic artery distensibility [15,23], the authors properly conclude that the phenomenon may be due to adrenergic influences on vasomotor tone being more important for muscular- rather than for elastic-type arterial vessels. It should be also stressed, however, that in a variety of physiological or pathophysiological conditions, it has been shown that the patterns of the sympathetic activation may differ in different cardiovascular districts, with some of them showing an increase while others show no change or even a reduction [24]. This is the case, for example, for skin sympathetic nerve traffic, which in a variety of cardiovascular diseases (hypertension, obesity, heart failure) or non-cardiovascular diseases (cirrhosis) was shown to be normal while muscle sympathetic neural outflow appeared to be markedly enhanced [25,26]. Whatever the mechanisms responsible might be, the heterogeneous behaviour of sympathetic drive as well as of arterial distensibility in different cardiovascular districts further indicates the close link existing between the physiological and pathophysiological behaviour of these two variables.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Grassi et al. (2002) conducted an editorial in End-stage renal disease. Kidney transplantation was evaluated. Kidney transplantation in end-stage renal disease highlights an inverse relationship between sympathetic cardiovascular outflow and the distensibility properties of muscular-type arteries.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: